Learn to DM: Design an Adventure!
Posted: Sun Feb 11, 2024 12:41 am
Another common thing I hear from would-be DMs is "I'm not imaginative/creative. I can't think up an adventure. I wouldn't know where to start!"
Well worry no more. Coming up with adventures seems daunting at first but it is achievable and I'm here to walk you through with an example in progress. And I mean the entire process. This isn't one of those "draw the rest of the fucking owl" situations. I'm gonna take you through every step as I do it. I'm currently designing the third arc of my campaign and it will serve as a perfect example. Starting with a one shot rather than a campaign is the best way for beginners and my players are currently in a stargate-like situation with a portal that sends them random places, essentially making each arc its own one shot within the ongoing narrative.
Arc 1 saw them on a traditional dnd-like world where they accidentally opened a portal to Hell instead of closing it. Arc 2 saw them trapped in a time loop on a futuristic magitech world. This second arc has been very combat-lite, with no real fights to speak of and entirely social/exploration in nature. Now is not really the time to discuss the three states of play but if you aren't already aware, a game exists in one of those three states at any given time, combat, social, exploration. Examine your own game or watch an actual play and you should be able to identify these states as play progresses.
Point is, my players are going to be itching for some combat and Arc 3 is going to deliver. Simply put, I've picked a focus for the arc. The focus for Arc 2 was a cool sandbox time loop, mostly exploratory and some social. In times like these, the focuses are obvious but sometimes your one shot won't have a specific focus and will involve all three states in fairly equal measure, that is fine too. Balanced is a good place to start for a one shot and if so, that needs to be kept in mind as we will need to design combat, social encounters and things to explore.
Theme. To explain our theme choice I need to give a little context. The three characters in my game are from different worlds. One is from Ravnica, one is from the elemental plane of air and the third, Firion, is a duskblade from a custom world called Adanis. Adanis has, historically, been besieged by barghests leading goblin armies, basically using Firion's world as a training ground both for the goblin armies and for the barghest themselves to advance with their feed ability. This is a golden opportunity to return to Firion's world for some combat. The players are level 6 going on 7 so goblins and goblinoids are the perfect challenge level. What's more, this is the perfect opportunity to blow my player's minds by revealing that the portal doesn't just take them through space but through time. We're going back to Firion's world but not within Firion's lifetime. We're going 110 years into the past, to a point in Adanis's history where the barghest invasion almost wiped out the entire population. They were eventually turned aside but fewer than 2000 people survived. Firion's people are still recovering, leaving them in an early medieval state in contrast to his companions.
And so our theme is clear. Goblins.
Coupled with our combat focus, we now have the basis for this adventure. I decided on a concept of a fort defence style arc, with the last bastion of humanity holding out against superior goblin numbers, drawing on influences from mythology and fiction such as 300 and the defence of Tarwin's Gap in the Wheel of Time. I've run fort defence style stuff before and have run these players through Hoard of the Dragon Queen in 5e so they have experienced this style of thing twice in there as well so it's an area we're all comfortable with.
I didn't want them to simply portal into the fort and begin mid siege though. I had the idea of giving them a personal stake not only for Firion, whose history is on the line, but for the other characters too and to do this, I wanted them to start in media res, as the goblins are attacking civilians. Thinking about how to achieve this I decided I wanted them to have to roll initiative as soon as they go through the portal with little chance to figure out where they are or what's going on, leaving them as confused and panicked as the civilians. To that end, I decided I needed some fleeing civilians, heading to the fort for safety. I settled on a pretty simple fight to open with. The players arrive, I describe the wild west style scenery with desert scrubland and the screams as they realise civilians are fleeing, being chased by goblins mounted on worgs, two of which are barrelling straight towards the players. This should also telegraph that this is going to be a combat heavy segment. Two goblin worg riders are EL4, not too tough for our three level 6s. They lack any dedicated frontliner or mage, having a duskblade, a rogue and a warlock. The action economy is against them initially but they only have to kill one goblin to balance that or two to shift the economy in their favour. Pretty manageable.
Then I figured that to make it clear the stakes are high, the people aren't just fleeing, they are trying to defend wagons. Specifically supply wagons. And those wagons are being attacked. I wrote a quick bit of description explaining how the defenders around one wagon are falling as it is attacked by hobgoblins riding dire wolves, giving the players an EL5 encounter to take down these tougher enemies and defend the wagon.
Once these outriders are dealt with, I plan to give the players some info. They can see the goblin army off in the distance, behind the abandoned town. They're following, but they're slower. They'll also soon realise they're heading to the fort and Firion may even realise they're on his world.
This opening section is how I do a lot of my one shot work. I find that having a good interesting opening sets me up nicely for looking at what else I can do. It doesn't always have to be a dramatic set piece but it certainly doesn't hurt to consider it. The prologue and Arc 2 opened in a similar manner with only Arc 1 opening in a cold exploration state.
But now I have this opening section done. Where do I go? Well, to the end of course. How does this adventure end, what's the win condition? I decided that the goal here is to achieve what historically happened and that is that this was the turning point in the war. This was where the first barghest general fell. So there's our finale. A fight against the barghest general, a personal milestone for Firion and a fun encounter for the whole party. But before we get there, we need to raise the stakes.
So we're looking at a fort defence where the fort is nestled between the mountains. I need two things. First, interesting encounter ideas and second, interesting enemy ideas. I started jotting down ideas and here are my exact notes, so you can follow along my thought process.
Barghest general
Fort layout
Supply details (dwindling)
Handful of NPCs (names)
Basic goblins Fighter 1? 2?
Some sort of hidden path like in 300
A traitor is using it to slip out. The fort's commander is using it to smuggle supplies in. Maybe a band of hobgoblins make it through.
Barricade repairs, sentry duty.
Excursion to destroy siege weaponry (at night?)
Goblin rogue sneaks in at night to poison the well. What if there are two threats at the same time, this and the hobgoblin band. Maybe one group try to poison the well, the other tries to destroy the armoury where the spare arrows and ballistas are. The PCs can only stop one group unless they figure something out.
One mass assault.
Defenders have low motivation.
Fort has sent for aid. When reinforcement arrives, insta refresh characters health and abilities and make one giant push to get the general.
Well, these are some good ideas to start with. Let's look at enemies. The barghest, obviously, and then some goblinoids. This being 3.5e we have plenty of options and so I went hunting through sourcebooks for goblinoids and plucked out things I liked. Basic goblins and hobgoblins of course. Blues, which are psionic goblins. The Vril from Drow of the Underdark, a goblinoid that has damage reduction (CR2). The Varag from the MM4, available in CR 1 or 5 for some interesting encounter builds, these are feral goblinoids that pack a punch. The hobgoblin duskblade (CR3) and warcaster (CR4) from the MM5. Now we have a lot of flavour to work with. We can mix and match these into some interesting encounters but we're not done. I also noted the goblin flesh herder (CR5) from Drow of the Underdark. Essentially a goblin necromancer who can command the undead. This really got my juices flowing and I began to think how this could be used.
What if the goblins have an initial reckless assault on the fort that the defenders turn aside easily? Only as the majority of the army retreat, the flesh herder starts raising the dead as goblin zombies. Zombie goblins. Zoblins, if you will. Someone needs to go out and deal with him before this gets out of hand but the archers have exhausted their arrow supply in the assault. The PCs can sally forth to face him, having to break through his wall of undead to take him on. Now, Zoblins are CR 1/2 so one Flesh Herder and 3 to 7 zoblins makes for an EL 6 encounter with a spike in perceived difficulty between 5 and 6 zoblins.
However, we can artificially nerf this a little by not having the flesh herder directly attack the PCs, instead focusing on resurrecting zombies. This gives them a sense of urgency both from the flavour text where we'll make it clear the fort commander wants him stopped before he undoes all the work they've just done killing the goblins, but also the longer they take to push through to the flesh herder the more zombies there will be. So we can start with 3 zoblins up and have him res the fourth on the first initiative count. Pretty fun stuff. If it does get out of hand the players can always retreat to the fort and leave the herder to his work (in which case, when the time comes for the final push for the general, the players will have to defeat a group of zoblins that wouldn't otherwise be there).
I'm also going to share another trick about how we can nerf this if it goes really badly with a trick I like to call Environmental Nerfing.
Sometimes, as DMs, we have to cheat. Fudge the dice. This is why we roll behind a screen. A TPK is not a desirable outcome and on rare occasions it's ok to intervene in fate. In a situation like this where the fight is manageable but the action economy is massively against the players (this is a party of three don't forget), a little deus ex machina could go a long way. Two of the PCs have very few hit points and could easily find themselves low on health and taking a crit. In 3.5, you die at -10hp. So having a method to potentially negate that, without just lying about the dice roll is a fun thing you can think up. It will seem like a scripted event in the game and the players will think you planned it that way all along. For example, let's say our warlock finds himself on 1hp and a zombie swings at him. I see a nat 20 come up and realise he's dead. Or is he? Right as the zombie swings at you, a rock falls from the battlements, squishing him where he stands. A defender looks over the parapet at you, grins and gives you a thumbs up.
Now we've turned a player death into a fun event and opened up a roleplay option when the players return to the fort. The players will think I had that little detail in the bag the whole time (which I kinda did) and they're none the wiser. Learn to do this. It will really up your game. Don't overdo it of course. But it feels a lot better on those rare occasions where you need to fudge to actually make it look like it was simply part of the set dressing.
The final note here for this part is that I want you to understand what we just achieved. We took an interesting creature idea, made it into an interesting encounter and have allowed that encounter to shape our narrative. Having this encounter necessitates the assault before it in order to form a cohesive narrative. Sometimes this will work the other way round and the story will shape the combat and that's ok too. This interplay between the narrative (the fluff) and the mechanics (the crunch) is what adventure design is all about.
So now we have an opening encounter against the outriders and an assault on the fort followed by our flesh herder encounter. This is starting to feel like Day 1 to me and so now I think about the plan. When the refugees get to the fort, what if the commander sends for reinforcements to the nearest town beyond. He estimates nearly two days travel there, two back and a day to mobilise the forces. That makes six days to hold the fort if we count today.
Ok let's refine Day 1.
The two fights against the outriders sets us up nicely but I don't really want the PCs to have to fight more groups of outriders as they approach the fort, but I want it to feel like they did. We'll let the narrative do the heavy lifting here and simply have a descriptive passage describing how the outriders make a last lacklustre attempt to damage the wagons but are turned back by the defenders and the PCs, with the defenders cheering and giving the PCs a thumbs up as the riders fall away to retreat back to the main force. This gives a little camaraderie and lets the PCs know these people accept them and clearly need their assistance. We'll reinforce that necessity when they get to the fort.
They find a man in charge who led the refugees here. His name is Barandion and although Firion doesn't know it yet, this is his great grandfather. He will tell the PCs that these people are mostly farmers and craftsman from the town of Gevel's Oasis, which we saw them escaping from at the start. He'll give some context. The goblin forces are just a vanguard, roaming ahead of the main army to find towns and villages to raid. Thankfully they were spotted on the approach and the people had just enough time to grab supplies and flee. They'll follow, thinking the group small enough to deal with but once they find the fort, they will send word back to the main army and request reinforcements. It is Barandion's hope that his reinforcements will arrive first. He sends two riders north to Betan to fetch men and supplies. In the mean time, this fort needs defending. Barandion expects the goblins will make an initial assault to test the defences and try to end things quickly. If they can turn this assault away, they stand a good chance.
Now the PCs can make some preparations. One of my PCs has a jury-rigging skill that allows him to create makeshift constructions and this will be an ideal point to let him roll to put together some barricades. Maybe the fort's one ballista is damaged and he can assist in repairing it. Another has an administration skill that can be put to use cataloguing the supplies of food and ammunition and drawing up rationing to last the six days. This frees up Firion to talk to his people, maybe even his grandfather if he's figured it out. As the most obviously martial of the group, people are looking to Firion for reassurance.
At this point I've also begun looking at the adventure Red Hand of Doom which has a fort defence against goblinoids, though designed for higher level players. Still, there's some stuff I want to borrow here. First up there's some premade enemies. Upgraded Worg Riders, Hobgoblin regulars, sergeants, veterans, bladebearers, clerics and monks, all around CR 3-5. This saves me a little work as we can pepper these into encounters too to have a little variance. There's also a couple of scenarios in their fort defence that I might borrow for subsequent days, adjusting the difficulty downwards to compensate.
So, day 1 is looking good. At this point I want to look at the end again. In my initial notes I had the idea of the reinforcements arriving and the PCs getting a refresh. HP, after all, is not a measure of wounds but of willingness to continue fighting, but in order for this refresh to feel significant, the PCs must first be beleaguered. Night 5 then, is another assault, under cover of darkness, the goblins taking advantage of their innate darkvision and the moonless night. Then, when morning comes and the reinforcements arrive, the refresh will be justified. Hell, with the supplies arriving too, the PCs will get the best breakfast they've had in days. Maybe we'll give them a buff of sorts, like the temp HP benefits of Heroes' Feast, leaving them fit and raring to go for Barandion's plan. The fort's scouts have seen the main force off in the distance, maybe a day's march away. This is the last chance. The goblins are weakened after their nighttime assault. Barandion wants to make a push for the general. His plan is to use riders to help clear a path but the newly arrived soldiers' horses are tired so they can only put together a small mounted unit using the fort's existing horses. These riders will help clear a path and with two flanking units of fresh soldiers to assist, the PCs can pierce through the army to face the general. The other solders will guard their rear and minimize interference while the PCs engage the barghest. I'm thinking they face maybe two groups of enemies then the barghest with adds (and zoblins if the flesh herder escaped previously).
Now, let's dance back and look at day 2. You'll notice I'm jumping back and forth a lot and I've left this in on purpose. I think sometimes players think DMs start at the beginning, write til the end and then dust off their hands and they're done. Don't be afraid to flit back and forth, building your framework then refining the details as they become apparent. I'm looking at day 2 now because I had an idea. On day 2, the goblins start building some siege equipment. A tower and a catapult or two. I want the PCs to intervene in this and I want them to do so without fearing that they have to face the whole army alone. So, the stuff is being built near the trees a short distance away from the fort. The PCs could take horses and engage the builders and destroy the equipment. My players are kinda cowardly so they won't go for this in case the riders come for them so I have to make it clear that they could pull off this raid without fear of interference. So, in the morning, a scout reports that the riders have left the goblin camp. The bulk have headed east and four to the west. Later, Barandion will speculate that the larger force have gone to forage for food and water to supplement the army's supplies. It will soon become apparent as they are observed that the smaller force is building siege weapons. Barandion suggests riding out on horseback to destroy them before the camp can respond but suggests to wait, in order for them to waste the day at their labours, setting them back as much as possible. The raid will take place in the afternoon.
Now, four riders of any sort would be a bit much for the players to handle so we need to account for that. Having an NPC with them would help, maybe two. It needs to be tough because the PCs will be at full strength. We'll fine tune the balancing later when we start detailing the encounters. For now, we consider this a raid with NPC allies.
Because choice is important, we'll also offer a second option here. That of waiting for nightfall then infiltrating the camp and burning the siege equipment. This gives the PCs a stealth option with either no combat or one small fight if spotted. This should appeal to the party's rogue. The warlock also has access to Disguise Self. Success here will be far more demoralizing for the goblins but failure means they can bring siege to bear during the night time assault we discussed.
At this point, I'm wondering if 6 days is really necessary. Don't be afraid of going back and changing things. I'm now thinking 4 days is a good amount to keep this whole siege action packed. That means we have day 1 sorted and day 4 (what was day 6). So we need to flesh out day 2 and then work on day 3.
For day 2, I like the idea of the PCs returning home to find that something bad happened in their absence. Red Hand of Doom has a sniper infiltrate the fort and I'm going to steal that idea and modify it. If the PCs fight the siege makers in the day, this is day 2 afternoon/evening. If they did it at night then this can be at night. The premise is that a small bunch of goblins, maybe 3, managed to sneak into the fort's chapel. They are taking potshots at people from the tower and are darn good shots. Our fort defence now has another fort defence taking place inside it. The PCs need to breach the chapel, which the gobboes have heavily trapped (because our party has a rogue) and take them down. They can try talking them down but the gobboes are having none of it. Because we like to get silly sometimes the gobboes will respond with jeers and insults and gestures of defiance like wiggling their bare bums out the windows and suchlike. Again, we'll detail the numbers later but for now, we have shaped out day 2.
We'll end the day with another assault on the walls just as twilight starts to descend. If the PCs assaulted the siege weapons at night then the assault happens in retaliation immediately after they've dealt with the infiltrators. Let's say the gobboes have built ladders out of the debris of the siege equipment. They've also waited for it to darken to minimize the effect of the fort's archers and they have got their spellslingers for support to try and keep them at bay. PCs can run around the walls, kicking away ladders and engaging groups of gobboes. Every round there's a 10% chance one of them is hit by a stray spell for 1d4 fire damage. This is what you new kids now call a lair action. Bringing the environment to life can be a fun thing. Also, if the goblins successfully built their siege equipment, they use the catapults to hurl boulders (1d10 bludge damage, ref DC 14 for half, 20% chance per round) or goblins (30% chance of a random gobbo joining any fight the PCs are in, every round). If the flesh herder is still around, the random gobbo has a 50% chance of being a zoblin. I may let a player snipe spellslingers to negate the chance, we'll see.
Day 2 is looking pretty complete so now we can look at day 3. The goblins are gonna ease off here in order to lull the fort into a false sense of security so they don't expect the big nighttime assault that leads us into our day 4 finale. Instead, they make a big show of building a useless MacGuffin as a distraction. I already mentioned how silly my group is, so the goblins are building what is clearly a Trojan Bugbear. The players can watch it take shape across the day amid concerns about dwindling supplies. The bugbear will be mostly built but clearly unfinished as night falls, hopefully making the players think that whatever dumb plan the goblins have, it will occur tomorrow. In the dead of night, the goblins attack the walls again with the same spell chance, siege weaponry and zoblin chances as the previous day. The PCs will defend again but this time, in complete darkness. Gobboes will focus archery fire on anyone holding a light source and will attempt to quench any torches they find up there. While this assault is determined, it is also another distraction. A small band of goblins has braved the mountains to slip into the fort through the rear. A breathless civilian arrives mid-assault to warn the PCs that he just saw two bands of gobboes in the fort. One was heading towards the well, another to the command centre. One band of gobboes will attempt to poison the well, the other to assassinate Barandion.
If the PCs rush to the well, they arrive just as the defenders fall, in time to stop the goblins but when they arrive at Barandion he is wounded and poisoned.
If they go for Barandion first they can fend off the assassins with ease but arrive at the well to find the defenders dead and the well poisoned.
The point here is to have the PCs choose. The strategic importance of the well over Firion's emotional attachment to his grandfather.
If they pick the well, Barandion will survive, being healed by a cleric when the reinforcements arrive.
If they choose Barandion, the cleric will instead use create water. Mechanically, I'm going to say that if they choose this option, they do not get the heroes' feast buff we talked about earlier due to the demoralizing effect on everyone at discovering the well is poisoned and the limited water rations available even with the cleric's assistance.
Ok, let's take one last look at the whole timeline in order, then we can start populating these encounters.
As we do this, remember that I started this with only two words in mind, combat and goblins. See how we've let encounters shape the narrative and the narrative shape encounters, not just by cause and effect but in reverse too, such as our refresh idea necessitating pushing the PCs to their limits prior. The effect required a cause.
Day 1 - PCs arrive outside Gevel's Oasis as the citizens are fleeing, harried by outriders attempting to cripple their supply wagons. The PCs face immediate threat from goblins riders and then are compelled to defend a wagon against hobgoblin riders. The wagons are slow and most of the civilians on foot, meaning the PCs can easily catch up. The scale of the threat becomes apparent as the group defends against the final raiders then retreats to the fort. Riders are immediately dispatched to Betan, the town beyond the pass, to request reinforcements and supplies. A response is expected in four days. The PCs have a little time after arriving to prepare their defences before the goblin vanguard arrives and launches an assault. The invasion is repelled but a flesh herder begins raising the dead. The PCs have to deal with him.
Day 2 - Riders leave the gobbo camp to get supplies while a smaller group make for the trees and begin assembling siege equipment. Players can engage these in a straight fight or wait for nightfall and infiltrate their camp. Either way, the PCs arrive back to find that a group of goblin scallywags have set up in the chapel and are sniping people. The PCs deal with this then have a brief respite before the assault. If the PCs successfully infiltrated the camp and burnt the siege equipment, the gobboes have a -1 morale penalty to attacks and damage during this assault. If the siege weapons survived, they are factored into the environmental effects.
Day 3 - The gobboes build a Trojan Bugbear to distract eyes towards the goblin camp. They leave it unfinished so the defenders think there will be no assault tonight. In the dead of night, the gobboes attack in force. Meanwhile, a handful of infiltrators have made it through the rear of the fort after traversing the mountains. They split into two groups, one to poison the well, one to assassinate Barandion. The PCs must choose which to prioritize. Failing to secure the well means they won't receive the bonus temporary hit points on day 4.
Day 4 - The reinforcements arrive. PCs get a refresh and (if they secured the well) temporary HP. Barandion outlines his plan to take down the barghest general. The PCs must fight a few groups of enemies before attempting to take him down. If successful, the army is routed as the gobboes' discipline fails them. If they fail... well, let's not consider that yet, but it could be phenomenally bad news for Firion. Maybe I'll have Barandion ride with them so we can make it a more memorable encounter. He is a duskblade like Firion after all.
I'm happy with this timeline so it's time to put the finishing touches in place. There are two things left to do. Populate the encounters, choose enemies, set ELs, work out xp and loot, the Crunch. And write some descriptive passages to set the scene prior to and following major events, the Fluff. I'm going to present them separately here to make it easier for you to follow but know that in reality, I tend to work on these simultaneously.
Well worry no more. Coming up with adventures seems daunting at first but it is achievable and I'm here to walk you through with an example in progress. And I mean the entire process. This isn't one of those "draw the rest of the fucking owl" situations. I'm gonna take you through every step as I do it. I'm currently designing the third arc of my campaign and it will serve as a perfect example. Starting with a one shot rather than a campaign is the best way for beginners and my players are currently in a stargate-like situation with a portal that sends them random places, essentially making each arc its own one shot within the ongoing narrative.
Arc 1 saw them on a traditional dnd-like world where they accidentally opened a portal to Hell instead of closing it. Arc 2 saw them trapped in a time loop on a futuristic magitech world. This second arc has been very combat-lite, with no real fights to speak of and entirely social/exploration in nature. Now is not really the time to discuss the three states of play but if you aren't already aware, a game exists in one of those three states at any given time, combat, social, exploration. Examine your own game or watch an actual play and you should be able to identify these states as play progresses.
Point is, my players are going to be itching for some combat and Arc 3 is going to deliver. Simply put, I've picked a focus for the arc. The focus for Arc 2 was a cool sandbox time loop, mostly exploratory and some social. In times like these, the focuses are obvious but sometimes your one shot won't have a specific focus and will involve all three states in fairly equal measure, that is fine too. Balanced is a good place to start for a one shot and if so, that needs to be kept in mind as we will need to design combat, social encounters and things to explore.
Theme. To explain our theme choice I need to give a little context. The three characters in my game are from different worlds. One is from Ravnica, one is from the elemental plane of air and the third, Firion, is a duskblade from a custom world called Adanis. Adanis has, historically, been besieged by barghests leading goblin armies, basically using Firion's world as a training ground both for the goblin armies and for the barghest themselves to advance with their feed ability. This is a golden opportunity to return to Firion's world for some combat. The players are level 6 going on 7 so goblins and goblinoids are the perfect challenge level. What's more, this is the perfect opportunity to blow my player's minds by revealing that the portal doesn't just take them through space but through time. We're going back to Firion's world but not within Firion's lifetime. We're going 110 years into the past, to a point in Adanis's history where the barghest invasion almost wiped out the entire population. They were eventually turned aside but fewer than 2000 people survived. Firion's people are still recovering, leaving them in an early medieval state in contrast to his companions.
And so our theme is clear. Goblins.
Coupled with our combat focus, we now have the basis for this adventure. I decided on a concept of a fort defence style arc, with the last bastion of humanity holding out against superior goblin numbers, drawing on influences from mythology and fiction such as 300 and the defence of Tarwin's Gap in the Wheel of Time. I've run fort defence style stuff before and have run these players through Hoard of the Dragon Queen in 5e so they have experienced this style of thing twice in there as well so it's an area we're all comfortable with.
I didn't want them to simply portal into the fort and begin mid siege though. I had the idea of giving them a personal stake not only for Firion, whose history is on the line, but for the other characters too and to do this, I wanted them to start in media res, as the goblins are attacking civilians. Thinking about how to achieve this I decided I wanted them to have to roll initiative as soon as they go through the portal with little chance to figure out where they are or what's going on, leaving them as confused and panicked as the civilians. To that end, I decided I needed some fleeing civilians, heading to the fort for safety. I settled on a pretty simple fight to open with. The players arrive, I describe the wild west style scenery with desert scrubland and the screams as they realise civilians are fleeing, being chased by goblins mounted on worgs, two of which are barrelling straight towards the players. This should also telegraph that this is going to be a combat heavy segment. Two goblin worg riders are EL4, not too tough for our three level 6s. They lack any dedicated frontliner or mage, having a duskblade, a rogue and a warlock. The action economy is against them initially but they only have to kill one goblin to balance that or two to shift the economy in their favour. Pretty manageable.
Then I figured that to make it clear the stakes are high, the people aren't just fleeing, they are trying to defend wagons. Specifically supply wagons. And those wagons are being attacked. I wrote a quick bit of description explaining how the defenders around one wagon are falling as it is attacked by hobgoblins riding dire wolves, giving the players an EL5 encounter to take down these tougher enemies and defend the wagon.
Once these outriders are dealt with, I plan to give the players some info. They can see the goblin army off in the distance, behind the abandoned town. They're following, but they're slower. They'll also soon realise they're heading to the fort and Firion may even realise they're on his world.
This opening section is how I do a lot of my one shot work. I find that having a good interesting opening sets me up nicely for looking at what else I can do. It doesn't always have to be a dramatic set piece but it certainly doesn't hurt to consider it. The prologue and Arc 2 opened in a similar manner with only Arc 1 opening in a cold exploration state.
But now I have this opening section done. Where do I go? Well, to the end of course. How does this adventure end, what's the win condition? I decided that the goal here is to achieve what historically happened and that is that this was the turning point in the war. This was where the first barghest general fell. So there's our finale. A fight against the barghest general, a personal milestone for Firion and a fun encounter for the whole party. But before we get there, we need to raise the stakes.
So we're looking at a fort defence where the fort is nestled between the mountains. I need two things. First, interesting encounter ideas and second, interesting enemy ideas. I started jotting down ideas and here are my exact notes, so you can follow along my thought process.
Barghest general
Fort layout
Supply details (dwindling)
Handful of NPCs (names)
Basic goblins Fighter 1? 2?
Some sort of hidden path like in 300
A traitor is using it to slip out. The fort's commander is using it to smuggle supplies in. Maybe a band of hobgoblins make it through.
Barricade repairs, sentry duty.
Excursion to destroy siege weaponry (at night?)
Goblin rogue sneaks in at night to poison the well. What if there are two threats at the same time, this and the hobgoblin band. Maybe one group try to poison the well, the other tries to destroy the armoury where the spare arrows and ballistas are. The PCs can only stop one group unless they figure something out.
One mass assault.
Defenders have low motivation.
Fort has sent for aid. When reinforcement arrives, insta refresh characters health and abilities and make one giant push to get the general.
Well, these are some good ideas to start with. Let's look at enemies. The barghest, obviously, and then some goblinoids. This being 3.5e we have plenty of options and so I went hunting through sourcebooks for goblinoids and plucked out things I liked. Basic goblins and hobgoblins of course. Blues, which are psionic goblins. The Vril from Drow of the Underdark, a goblinoid that has damage reduction (CR2). The Varag from the MM4, available in CR 1 or 5 for some interesting encounter builds, these are feral goblinoids that pack a punch. The hobgoblin duskblade (CR3) and warcaster (CR4) from the MM5. Now we have a lot of flavour to work with. We can mix and match these into some interesting encounters but we're not done. I also noted the goblin flesh herder (CR5) from Drow of the Underdark. Essentially a goblin necromancer who can command the undead. This really got my juices flowing and I began to think how this could be used.
What if the goblins have an initial reckless assault on the fort that the defenders turn aside easily? Only as the majority of the army retreat, the flesh herder starts raising the dead as goblin zombies. Zombie goblins. Zoblins, if you will. Someone needs to go out and deal with him before this gets out of hand but the archers have exhausted their arrow supply in the assault. The PCs can sally forth to face him, having to break through his wall of undead to take him on. Now, Zoblins are CR 1/2 so one Flesh Herder and 3 to 7 zoblins makes for an EL 6 encounter with a spike in perceived difficulty between 5 and 6 zoblins.
However, we can artificially nerf this a little by not having the flesh herder directly attack the PCs, instead focusing on resurrecting zombies. This gives them a sense of urgency both from the flavour text where we'll make it clear the fort commander wants him stopped before he undoes all the work they've just done killing the goblins, but also the longer they take to push through to the flesh herder the more zombies there will be. So we can start with 3 zoblins up and have him res the fourth on the first initiative count. Pretty fun stuff. If it does get out of hand the players can always retreat to the fort and leave the herder to his work (in which case, when the time comes for the final push for the general, the players will have to defeat a group of zoblins that wouldn't otherwise be there).
I'm also going to share another trick about how we can nerf this if it goes really badly with a trick I like to call Environmental Nerfing.
Sometimes, as DMs, we have to cheat. Fudge the dice. This is why we roll behind a screen. A TPK is not a desirable outcome and on rare occasions it's ok to intervene in fate. In a situation like this where the fight is manageable but the action economy is massively against the players (this is a party of three don't forget), a little deus ex machina could go a long way. Two of the PCs have very few hit points and could easily find themselves low on health and taking a crit. In 3.5, you die at -10hp. So having a method to potentially negate that, without just lying about the dice roll is a fun thing you can think up. It will seem like a scripted event in the game and the players will think you planned it that way all along. For example, let's say our warlock finds himself on 1hp and a zombie swings at him. I see a nat 20 come up and realise he's dead. Or is he? Right as the zombie swings at you, a rock falls from the battlements, squishing him where he stands. A defender looks over the parapet at you, grins and gives you a thumbs up.
Now we've turned a player death into a fun event and opened up a roleplay option when the players return to the fort. The players will think I had that little detail in the bag the whole time (which I kinda did) and they're none the wiser. Learn to do this. It will really up your game. Don't overdo it of course. But it feels a lot better on those rare occasions where you need to fudge to actually make it look like it was simply part of the set dressing.
The final note here for this part is that I want you to understand what we just achieved. We took an interesting creature idea, made it into an interesting encounter and have allowed that encounter to shape our narrative. Having this encounter necessitates the assault before it in order to form a cohesive narrative. Sometimes this will work the other way round and the story will shape the combat and that's ok too. This interplay between the narrative (the fluff) and the mechanics (the crunch) is what adventure design is all about.
So now we have an opening encounter against the outriders and an assault on the fort followed by our flesh herder encounter. This is starting to feel like Day 1 to me and so now I think about the plan. When the refugees get to the fort, what if the commander sends for reinforcements to the nearest town beyond. He estimates nearly two days travel there, two back and a day to mobilise the forces. That makes six days to hold the fort if we count today.
Ok let's refine Day 1.
The two fights against the outriders sets us up nicely but I don't really want the PCs to have to fight more groups of outriders as they approach the fort, but I want it to feel like they did. We'll let the narrative do the heavy lifting here and simply have a descriptive passage describing how the outriders make a last lacklustre attempt to damage the wagons but are turned back by the defenders and the PCs, with the defenders cheering and giving the PCs a thumbs up as the riders fall away to retreat back to the main force. This gives a little camaraderie and lets the PCs know these people accept them and clearly need their assistance. We'll reinforce that necessity when they get to the fort.
They find a man in charge who led the refugees here. His name is Barandion and although Firion doesn't know it yet, this is his great grandfather. He will tell the PCs that these people are mostly farmers and craftsman from the town of Gevel's Oasis, which we saw them escaping from at the start. He'll give some context. The goblin forces are just a vanguard, roaming ahead of the main army to find towns and villages to raid. Thankfully they were spotted on the approach and the people had just enough time to grab supplies and flee. They'll follow, thinking the group small enough to deal with but once they find the fort, they will send word back to the main army and request reinforcements. It is Barandion's hope that his reinforcements will arrive first. He sends two riders north to Betan to fetch men and supplies. In the mean time, this fort needs defending. Barandion expects the goblins will make an initial assault to test the defences and try to end things quickly. If they can turn this assault away, they stand a good chance.
Now the PCs can make some preparations. One of my PCs has a jury-rigging skill that allows him to create makeshift constructions and this will be an ideal point to let him roll to put together some barricades. Maybe the fort's one ballista is damaged and he can assist in repairing it. Another has an administration skill that can be put to use cataloguing the supplies of food and ammunition and drawing up rationing to last the six days. This frees up Firion to talk to his people, maybe even his grandfather if he's figured it out. As the most obviously martial of the group, people are looking to Firion for reassurance.
At this point I've also begun looking at the adventure Red Hand of Doom which has a fort defence against goblinoids, though designed for higher level players. Still, there's some stuff I want to borrow here. First up there's some premade enemies. Upgraded Worg Riders, Hobgoblin regulars, sergeants, veterans, bladebearers, clerics and monks, all around CR 3-5. This saves me a little work as we can pepper these into encounters too to have a little variance. There's also a couple of scenarios in their fort defence that I might borrow for subsequent days, adjusting the difficulty downwards to compensate.
So, day 1 is looking good. At this point I want to look at the end again. In my initial notes I had the idea of the reinforcements arriving and the PCs getting a refresh. HP, after all, is not a measure of wounds but of willingness to continue fighting, but in order for this refresh to feel significant, the PCs must first be beleaguered. Night 5 then, is another assault, under cover of darkness, the goblins taking advantage of their innate darkvision and the moonless night. Then, when morning comes and the reinforcements arrive, the refresh will be justified. Hell, with the supplies arriving too, the PCs will get the best breakfast they've had in days. Maybe we'll give them a buff of sorts, like the temp HP benefits of Heroes' Feast, leaving them fit and raring to go for Barandion's plan. The fort's scouts have seen the main force off in the distance, maybe a day's march away. This is the last chance. The goblins are weakened after their nighttime assault. Barandion wants to make a push for the general. His plan is to use riders to help clear a path but the newly arrived soldiers' horses are tired so they can only put together a small mounted unit using the fort's existing horses. These riders will help clear a path and with two flanking units of fresh soldiers to assist, the PCs can pierce through the army to face the general. The other solders will guard their rear and minimize interference while the PCs engage the barghest. I'm thinking they face maybe two groups of enemies then the barghest with adds (and zoblins if the flesh herder escaped previously).
Now, let's dance back and look at day 2. You'll notice I'm jumping back and forth a lot and I've left this in on purpose. I think sometimes players think DMs start at the beginning, write til the end and then dust off their hands and they're done. Don't be afraid to flit back and forth, building your framework then refining the details as they become apparent. I'm looking at day 2 now because I had an idea. On day 2, the goblins start building some siege equipment. A tower and a catapult or two. I want the PCs to intervene in this and I want them to do so without fearing that they have to face the whole army alone. So, the stuff is being built near the trees a short distance away from the fort. The PCs could take horses and engage the builders and destroy the equipment. My players are kinda cowardly so they won't go for this in case the riders come for them so I have to make it clear that they could pull off this raid without fear of interference. So, in the morning, a scout reports that the riders have left the goblin camp. The bulk have headed east and four to the west. Later, Barandion will speculate that the larger force have gone to forage for food and water to supplement the army's supplies. It will soon become apparent as they are observed that the smaller force is building siege weapons. Barandion suggests riding out on horseback to destroy them before the camp can respond but suggests to wait, in order for them to waste the day at their labours, setting them back as much as possible. The raid will take place in the afternoon.
Now, four riders of any sort would be a bit much for the players to handle so we need to account for that. Having an NPC with them would help, maybe two. It needs to be tough because the PCs will be at full strength. We'll fine tune the balancing later when we start detailing the encounters. For now, we consider this a raid with NPC allies.
Because choice is important, we'll also offer a second option here. That of waiting for nightfall then infiltrating the camp and burning the siege equipment. This gives the PCs a stealth option with either no combat or one small fight if spotted. This should appeal to the party's rogue. The warlock also has access to Disguise Self. Success here will be far more demoralizing for the goblins but failure means they can bring siege to bear during the night time assault we discussed.
At this point, I'm wondering if 6 days is really necessary. Don't be afraid of going back and changing things. I'm now thinking 4 days is a good amount to keep this whole siege action packed. That means we have day 1 sorted and day 4 (what was day 6). So we need to flesh out day 2 and then work on day 3.
For day 2, I like the idea of the PCs returning home to find that something bad happened in their absence. Red Hand of Doom has a sniper infiltrate the fort and I'm going to steal that idea and modify it. If the PCs fight the siege makers in the day, this is day 2 afternoon/evening. If they did it at night then this can be at night. The premise is that a small bunch of goblins, maybe 3, managed to sneak into the fort's chapel. They are taking potshots at people from the tower and are darn good shots. Our fort defence now has another fort defence taking place inside it. The PCs need to breach the chapel, which the gobboes have heavily trapped (because our party has a rogue) and take them down. They can try talking them down but the gobboes are having none of it. Because we like to get silly sometimes the gobboes will respond with jeers and insults and gestures of defiance like wiggling their bare bums out the windows and suchlike. Again, we'll detail the numbers later but for now, we have shaped out day 2.
We'll end the day with another assault on the walls just as twilight starts to descend. If the PCs assaulted the siege weapons at night then the assault happens in retaliation immediately after they've dealt with the infiltrators. Let's say the gobboes have built ladders out of the debris of the siege equipment. They've also waited for it to darken to minimize the effect of the fort's archers and they have got their spellslingers for support to try and keep them at bay. PCs can run around the walls, kicking away ladders and engaging groups of gobboes. Every round there's a 10% chance one of them is hit by a stray spell for 1d4 fire damage. This is what you new kids now call a lair action. Bringing the environment to life can be a fun thing. Also, if the goblins successfully built their siege equipment, they use the catapults to hurl boulders (1d10 bludge damage, ref DC 14 for half, 20% chance per round) or goblins (30% chance of a random gobbo joining any fight the PCs are in, every round). If the flesh herder is still around, the random gobbo has a 50% chance of being a zoblin. I may let a player snipe spellslingers to negate the chance, we'll see.
Day 2 is looking pretty complete so now we can look at day 3. The goblins are gonna ease off here in order to lull the fort into a false sense of security so they don't expect the big nighttime assault that leads us into our day 4 finale. Instead, they make a big show of building a useless MacGuffin as a distraction. I already mentioned how silly my group is, so the goblins are building what is clearly a Trojan Bugbear. The players can watch it take shape across the day amid concerns about dwindling supplies. The bugbear will be mostly built but clearly unfinished as night falls, hopefully making the players think that whatever dumb plan the goblins have, it will occur tomorrow. In the dead of night, the goblins attack the walls again with the same spell chance, siege weaponry and zoblin chances as the previous day. The PCs will defend again but this time, in complete darkness. Gobboes will focus archery fire on anyone holding a light source and will attempt to quench any torches they find up there. While this assault is determined, it is also another distraction. A small band of goblins has braved the mountains to slip into the fort through the rear. A breathless civilian arrives mid-assault to warn the PCs that he just saw two bands of gobboes in the fort. One was heading towards the well, another to the command centre. One band of gobboes will attempt to poison the well, the other to assassinate Barandion.
If the PCs rush to the well, they arrive just as the defenders fall, in time to stop the goblins but when they arrive at Barandion he is wounded and poisoned.
If they go for Barandion first they can fend off the assassins with ease but arrive at the well to find the defenders dead and the well poisoned.
The point here is to have the PCs choose. The strategic importance of the well over Firion's emotional attachment to his grandfather.
If they pick the well, Barandion will survive, being healed by a cleric when the reinforcements arrive.
If they choose Barandion, the cleric will instead use create water. Mechanically, I'm going to say that if they choose this option, they do not get the heroes' feast buff we talked about earlier due to the demoralizing effect on everyone at discovering the well is poisoned and the limited water rations available even with the cleric's assistance.
Ok, let's take one last look at the whole timeline in order, then we can start populating these encounters.
As we do this, remember that I started this with only two words in mind, combat and goblins. See how we've let encounters shape the narrative and the narrative shape encounters, not just by cause and effect but in reverse too, such as our refresh idea necessitating pushing the PCs to their limits prior. The effect required a cause.
Day 1 - PCs arrive outside Gevel's Oasis as the citizens are fleeing, harried by outriders attempting to cripple their supply wagons. The PCs face immediate threat from goblins riders and then are compelled to defend a wagon against hobgoblin riders. The wagons are slow and most of the civilians on foot, meaning the PCs can easily catch up. The scale of the threat becomes apparent as the group defends against the final raiders then retreats to the fort. Riders are immediately dispatched to Betan, the town beyond the pass, to request reinforcements and supplies. A response is expected in four days. The PCs have a little time after arriving to prepare their defences before the goblin vanguard arrives and launches an assault. The invasion is repelled but a flesh herder begins raising the dead. The PCs have to deal with him.
Day 2 - Riders leave the gobbo camp to get supplies while a smaller group make for the trees and begin assembling siege equipment. Players can engage these in a straight fight or wait for nightfall and infiltrate their camp. Either way, the PCs arrive back to find that a group of goblin scallywags have set up in the chapel and are sniping people. The PCs deal with this then have a brief respite before the assault. If the PCs successfully infiltrated the camp and burnt the siege equipment, the gobboes have a -1 morale penalty to attacks and damage during this assault. If the siege weapons survived, they are factored into the environmental effects.
Day 3 - The gobboes build a Trojan Bugbear to distract eyes towards the goblin camp. They leave it unfinished so the defenders think there will be no assault tonight. In the dead of night, the gobboes attack in force. Meanwhile, a handful of infiltrators have made it through the rear of the fort after traversing the mountains. They split into two groups, one to poison the well, one to assassinate Barandion. The PCs must choose which to prioritize. Failing to secure the well means they won't receive the bonus temporary hit points on day 4.
Day 4 - The reinforcements arrive. PCs get a refresh and (if they secured the well) temporary HP. Barandion outlines his plan to take down the barghest general. The PCs must fight a few groups of enemies before attempting to take him down. If successful, the army is routed as the gobboes' discipline fails them. If they fail... well, let's not consider that yet, but it could be phenomenally bad news for Firion. Maybe I'll have Barandion ride with them so we can make it a more memorable encounter. He is a duskblade like Firion after all.
I'm happy with this timeline so it's time to put the finishing touches in place. There are two things left to do. Populate the encounters, choose enemies, set ELs, work out xp and loot, the Crunch. And write some descriptive passages to set the scene prior to and following major events, the Fluff. I'm going to present them separately here to make it easier for you to follow but know that in reality, I tend to work on these simultaneously.



