Charon Deep Dives Malazan Book of the Fallen (Part Two)
Posted: Sun Mar 03, 2024 1:36 pm
We're back, for a dive into book two, Deadhouse Gates and it's a meaty one, about the size of LOTR.
Deadhouse Gates
It is the 1163rd year of Burn's Sleep. 9th Year of the Reign of Empress Laseen.
We begin with a stark reminder that Malazan is a grimdark setting. We see Felisin, who you might remember is the younger sister of Ganoes Paran and she is in chains on a line of prisoners. It seems Empress Laseen has culled the nobles of Unta although it's not just the aristocracy on the chain. Next to Felisin is a large, bestial man named Baudin and a priest of Fener named Heboric, covered in tattoos resembling his god, the Boar of Summer. Heboric has no hands, his wrists ending in scarred, suppurating stumps.
At the same time, a priest of Hood is slowly approaching the chain of prisoners. He is covered in flies which have been drawn to the blood covering his body, a ritual in which Hood's priests smear themselves with the blood of executed murderers. This rite is part of the season of rot, performed by the priests when there is pestilence. The priest of Hood approaches the chain and exchanges words with Heboric. Then, suddenly, the cloud of flies bursts apart to reveal... no one. This unsettles Heboric and his fellow prisoners who wonder if this was a direct visitation by Hood himself.
A mob is forming and Felisin sees a familiar face on horseback behind them. Tavore... Adjunct Tavore. Her sister and the new embodiment of Empress Laseen's will. It seems Tavore was involved in orchestrating this cull.
As the guards try to move the prisoners, the mob attacks. Heboric protects Felisin as it gets gory. Eventually the mob are stopped when Baudin violently decapitates one of the female prisoners to appease their bloodlust.
This backdrop of plague, pestilence and violence in the Malazan Empire is gonna be a thing for a while. Our key takeaway from this prologue is that Tavore is the new Adjunct and her sister enslaved. Heboric seems highly respected and has been punished for challenging Empress Laseen's version of historic events.
We move forward, to year 1164 and find ourselves in the Pan'potsun Odhan, a desert. This book is gonna get very desert-y.
Here we meet Mappo Runt, a Trell, who is anything but a runt. He is in the company of a half-Jaghut with grey skin tanned olive green by the sun. His name, is Icarium. The two appear to be friends and it soon becomes apparent that Icarium has some degree of memory loss. They are wary that there is a demon somewhere nearby. They believe it to belong to Sha'ik who has an army nearby. Mappo goes to scout and Icarium sets about looking after his weapons, a longbow and sword.
As night falls they approach some ruins and we learn that the Holy Raraku desert flanks this one to the west. We get some subtle hints that Mappo knows things Icarium does not. They find the marks of many tiny claws near the ruins and realise they are the marks of rats, but not normal rats. These are the marks of a D'ivers, a shapeshifter who exists as multiple creatures. They believe this one to be Gryllen. Icarium laments that there will be others, following the Path to Ascendancy. It seems we have our first sense of convergence here. Icarium is following the Path in the hope of finding answers. Privately, Mappo laments that the answers will bring Icarium no peace. Icarium says he has lived for centuries, yet has no memories of his past. Mappo seems sad for Icarium but the moment is fleeting as they sense another D'ivers approaching. This one is in the form of six wolves, Mappo names him Ryllandaras. They opt to try conversing with him and the pack of wolves communicates telepathically. There's an exchange and when Ryllandaras realises this is Mappo and Icarium, he changes his tune swiftly, promising them no harm, that he was following the demon and came upon them by coincidence. During this exchange, privately Mappo hopes that Ryllandaras will leave before angering Icarium and "unleashing all I am sworn to prevent". They warn the D'ivers that the demon is with Sha'ik but he seems unconcerned, not knowing who that is. The pair think that he soon will.
We jump over to Seven Cities, the sub-continent north of Quon Tali that is under the control of the Malazan Empire. We're in a city called Hissar which isn't one of the Seven Cities from which this area draws its name. There we meet Duiker, an Imperial Historian and Mallick Rel, chief advisor to High Fist Pormqual (who is the commander of the Malazan armies on Seven Cities). Mallick is also a priest of Mael, the Elder god of the seas. Just for now, I want you to know, Mael is one of my favourite gods in this series. You won't find out why for a while. Anyways, they're here to welcome Coltaine as the new Fist of the Malazan 7th Army. This is a political move by the Empress. Coltaine was previously a rebel who fought against the Malazans and by putting him in a position of power, Laseen hopes to quell the potential uprising of rebels within the Empire. We also briefly meet Kulp, a white haired wizard who is a mage in the 7th Army.
We now jump to a boat where Fiddler, Kalam, Crokus and Apsalar are sailing to Ehrlitan, actually one the seven cities on Seven Cities. They have a run in with a giant sea serpent, a dhenrabi. They aren't usually found in waters this shallow but it soon becomes apparent that this dhenrabi is a Soletaken, another shapeshifter. The Soletaken warns the humans that it must kill them for having witnessed its passage. It attacks but Fiddler fires a munition from his crossbow and blows its head to smithereens. The Malazans are suspicious as to why the Soletaken was here. Spoilers, we know already. The shapeshifters are converging. But Kalam and Fiddler can't figure it out and so they continue heading to a small village outside Ehrlitan. Crokus demands some answers. He thinks Kalam and Fiddler only agreed to return Apsalar to Quon Tali in order to pursue their own agenda. The two admit it. Kalam is an assassin and this is a business trip. Kalam intends to assassinate...
Did you figure it out?
...Empress Laseen.
Dun dun DUN!!
Well damn. One chapter in and the stakes are enormous already.
Duiker has a walk around Hissar, giving us some local flavour before eventually arriving at a meeting with Coltaine. Also present is Coltaine's second in command, Bult, Mallick Rel and Kulp. We find a little of the history of Coltaine's fight with the Malazans. It seems Bult almost killed Duiker in that conflict before realising he was unarmed. Although he refrained, he was attacked by Dujek who scarred his face with his sword, but Bult's horse bit Dujek's arm, ultimately infecting it and causing its amputation later. Now we know how he became Dujek Onearm.
The meeting hasn't begun yet because Coltaine is waiting on his warlock. This surprises Duiker who thought all the Wickan warlocks were killed when the conflict was won by the Malazans. To summarize, Laseen ordered them all spiked up outside the walls. Coltaine is from the Crow Clan and they believe that the crows took the spirits of the dying warlocks and brought them back to his people to be reborn. When the warlock enters, a young teen boy, he claims to be Sormo E'nath. Kulp is outwardly dismissive but later, privately confesses to Duiker that the boy shows way more power than he has any right to and is probably the real Sormo E'nath reborn. Anyways, Mallick Rel says he has orders from Pormqual and Coltaine instantly dismisses them and Rel from the meeting. Duiker and Coltaine discuss some political issues. We learn that Crust was High Fist before Pormqual and that he drowned at night, despite being a strong swimmer and his body was never found. He was one of Kellanved's close friends and we learn that those are all dead with no bodies found either, including Toc the Elder and Ameron. They discuss whether it was Laseen cleaning house or whether someone else wished to deny Laseen the solid counsel Kellanved had access to. The meeting ends with Coltaine attaching Duiker to the 7th.
As I mentioned, Duiker and Kulp converse in private where Kulp claims the warlock is genuine and that he intends not to let on, in the hopes the warlock might consider him insignificant. They also express some surprise that both Coltaine and Bult seem loyal to the Empress.
Duiker isn't done. He has a personal favour to ask of Kulp. He wants help in freeing a prisoner from the Otataral Mines. Kulp is less than enthusiastic, Otataral kills sorcery, sends mages insane. Duiker promises they'll just be in a boat nearby, ready to collect the escapee and retreat. Kulp asks who they're freeing. Duiker names him Heboric Light Touch. Well, well, well. Kulp is still hesitant and when pressed by Duiker says he worries about releasing a second traitorous historian into the world.
Back to Ehrlitan to catch up with Fiddler. He witnesses some rebels killing people and in the confusion a pimp snatches two young girls whose mother is killed. One 9, the other smaller. Fiddler follows the pimp and manages to rescue the girls before they are violated. He returns them back to their people where they recognise him as a Gral, a tribe local to Ehrlitan. As a reward, Fiddler is invited inside to speak to a Spiritwalker. The two converse, the Spiritwalker has heard of the Bridgeburners. Fiddler confesses he is not a Gral but a Malazan in disguise though not to fool the locals but to hide from the Malazans and says he wishes to get passage to Quon Tali. The Spiritwalker tells Fiddler that he will not find a boat to Quon Tali and instead must cross the Pan'potsun Odhan. He also warns that the whirlwind of the Apocalypse will emerge from Raraku and that there will be a convergence. Fiddler makes the connection with the Soletaken dhenrabi he killed. The Spiritwalker says the Soletaken and D'ivers are being drawn to a gate by the Prophecy of the Path of Hands. Fiddler doesn't understand why the shapeshifters would be seeking a warren's gate. The Spiritwalker doesn't know either but suggests the shapeshifters might not know either, drawn by instinct more than knowledge. The worry is that the last one standing might Ascend, to become a god of shapeshifters. He gives Fiddler some sort of magical conch shell as a gift. Fiddler discovers the Spiritwalker is named Kimloc and understand this is a great honour. There are details about how Kimloc has history with the bridgeburners but it's not important right now.
Fiddler returns to Kalam and tells him about the convergence in the Pan'potsun Odhan but holds back information about Kimloc lest Kalam go kill him.
Kalam goes off and meets a shady guy who owes him a favour but is reluctant to deliver. Kalam roughs him up a bit. To cut a long story short, Kalam discovers that this man has stolen a book from Pormqual. The Holy Book of Dryjhna. If the book is taken into Raraku Desert and given to Sha'ik it will release the whirlwind of the apocalypse. Kalam agrees to take the book to Sha'ik and the spy gives him instructions of a ritual that must be performed each day he holds the book. When Kalam leaves, the spy converses with someone else. This unknown figure converses with the spy and we realise this was a setup. The book has been foisted off onto Kalam and the ritual will allow him to be followed in order to lead them directly to Sha'ik so they can kill her and stop the apocalypse. Getting complicated, isn't it? I found it all pretty difficult to follow first time round.
We go back to Mappo and Icarium. They were attacked by another D'ivers, this one twelve leopards. They killed it though Mappo worried as he saw Icarium's anger rising but thankfully it subsided again. They carry on but realise another Soletaken is following them. A bear arrives, sembling back into the form of a man, Messremb. They converse and as before, Messremb recognises Icarium and wishes them no harm, veering back into a bear and heading off on his way.
Next the pair come across a man on a mule. This is fan favourite character Iskaral Pust, a somewhat crazy priest of shadow. Some comical scenes occur in which Pust falls from the mule and berates it, calling it Servant and demanding it bring him wine. The mule wanders off into a cave. As the pair help Pust up, a man emerges from the cave and Pust continues to call him Servant. Pust offers the pair shelter for the night in his tower which is occupied by hordes of flying monkeys which Pust claims are a curse he has to deal with but that he has also made use of them as servants.
As they climb Pust's tower, Icarium and Mappo converse. They think Pust is touched by Ammanas (Shadowthrone, Kellanved, remember?) and might be slightly mad but extremely powerful. Mappo notes a warren opened in the cave when the mule entered. Icarium also expresses some confusion as to why Mappo is wounded and Icarium's sword has blood on it as he does not remember fighting. Mappo assures him it was nothing, he was beset by a leopard as Icarium slept and used Icarium's sword to defend himself, that is all. Icarium is worried that he seems to have lost memories again and Mappo assures him that if anything important had happened, he would have told him.
And so chapter two comes to a close, leaving us with many questions about the relationship between this pair. Mappo is clearly lying to Icarium, but is it for his own good? Are these lies an act of friendship as Mappo claims? Or is Icarium being misled? What is it Icarium is capable of, that Mappo seems to fear so much? Well, we have seen the power of a full blooded Jaghut. Is it simply his heritage that is to be feared? I guess we'll read on and find out.
Oh dear. Back to Felisin, who is now 15. She's mid-coitus with a man named Beneth and it seems she's doing so in order to gain favours for herself and Heboric. We get a quick run down of the situation so far. Felisin discovered her body was valuable currency on the ship over here, managing to get her, Heboric and Baudin out of the hold. A valuable manoeuvre as many left down there died on the trip. Now in the mines, Felisin has attached herself to Beneth, not the big man on campus but certainly second dog behind him. The problem is that although Beneth is content to make life better for Felisin, he seems reluctant to do any favours for Heboric, agreeing to take him off duty pulling the heavy minecarts but only to put him to work ploughing the fields. Felisin has her suspicions that Captain Sawark, the guy in charge, has orders to see to it that Heboric dies here and intends to give him the most punishing duties to ensure that it happens. Beneth gives Felisin food and she returns back to Heboric to give it to him. Heboric doesn't approve of her newfound promiscuity even though he's grateful for the benefits it brings. He has other concerns. Felisin has been drinking and smoking durhang. Felisin wants to say nice things to Heboric but finds herself being mean instead and the pair have a falling out.
Back in Hissar, the Red Blades arrive by boat. These are a Malazan unit of fanatics made up of Seven Cities natives and the ones who caused the ruckus back when Fiddler rescued the two girls in Ehrlitan. Observed by Duiker and Kulp, it seems the Red Blades are about to attack the citizenry when some of Coltaine's Wickans step up to face off against them. Kulp steps in and manages to defuse the situation before it gets ugly.
Crokus and Fiddler have a chat about Kalam leaving. Kalam has left to deliver the book, hoping to further undermine Laseen's hold on the Empire. Fiddler disagreed, focusing on the fact that the plan is to kill Laseen, not bring down the entire Empire. Crokus is worried that Apsalar's skills left over from The Rope's possession make her Fiddler's backup plan. Fiddler claims that's not true, but it no doubt occurred to Kalam and if not him, Quick Ben for sure.
Back with Iskaral Pust for some more comedy. Mappo asks how to get to the library and after Pust finishes giving him instructions containing a suspicious amount of right turns, the Trell replies "Or turn left, nineteen paces?".
He joins Icarium in the library. Icarium is surprised at the books he has found here. Well crafted, clearly expensive tomes, yet about trivial subjects such as seed dispersal patterns. What's more they seem to be thousands of years old.
Privately, Mappo is surprised Icarium is able to read the language. He tries to convince Icarium that the triviality of the knowledge was probably what led to the downfall of said civilization and even quotes Gothos' Folly to support his argument. He seems extremely keen to get Icarium off the subject of these older civilizations. He has a brief flashback to the time his tribe was approached by the Nameless Ones.
And back to the mines, where bodies are being removed from a collapse. Felisin realises that her actions have saved Heboric's life. Had she not had him removed to the fields, he would have been in that collapse. Indeed, the old priest has regained some of his vigour. Felisin laments that she and Heboric don't talk as much any more. He is upset at her durhang addiction but she can't think straight due to the substance, which I always presumed to be some kind of opiate given the dulling of mind and physical ravaging of body it causes, combined with its strong addictive quality. It has only been two weeks but already Felisin is in deep and many people here comment on her aged appearance. Sawark thinks she is nineteen and is surprised to learn she is actually fifteen. Anyways, Felisin has basically been offering herself around to fund this drug fuelled existence. Even Beneth is sick of her, describing her lovemaking as "torpid".
Beneth has a meeting with Captain Sawark, the man that runs the mines and takes Felisin with him. Beneth is seeking information about Baudin who has been arrested for violating curfew. There's some subtle hints that the two might have been friends in the past. Beneth is hoping to offer Felisin as a bribe but Sawark comments that nineteen is not young enough which is the aforementioned surprise. But there's something more here. Sawark pays her close attention and his face goes pale. The meeting ends swiftly.
Beneth takes Felisin outside and interrogates her, trying to figure out who she is that could cause Sawark such shock. Felisin pleads innocence, claiming to be a foundling who was at the temple of Fener when Heboric was arrested. Beneth thinks she's lying and might be a noble. He beats her severely but she sticks to her story, ultimately passing out beneath the blows.
Between the drugs and the battering Felisin struggles in and out of consciousness until eventually waking up back at the hovel she shares with Heboric, being attended to by the priest who is ministering to her wounds. She begs for durhang, for the pain and/or the addiction but is in no condition to smoke a pipe so Heboric reluctantly makes durhang tea for her.
Out in the desert, Kalam is on horseback when a sandstorm arises. He manages to make it to Ladro Landing before the worst of it and takes shelter in an inn. A Malaz sergeant tries to give him some grief but Kalam shows him a talisman that marks him as a Clawmaster and the sergeant drops his hostilities. A merchant's wife is also present with a deck of dragons, offering readings to the patrons. Another man and woman enter the inn, also seeking refuge from the storm. We'll cover them some more later. Right now we have no idea who they are or what they want. As the merchant's wife offers Kalam a reading and draws a card Kalam laughs. The card she drew is the Obelisk, a card that is inactive in Seven Cities and marks her as a fraud, with no skill in reading the deck. She tries to defend herself but Kalam rips her a new one, using his knowledge of the deck learned from being around it in the Bridgeburners. Angered, the woman chucks the deck at Kalam. Silence falls as the cards hit the floor... revealing a pattern. Kalam looks down to see a single card, The Rope, Assassin of Shadow, surrounded by six cards, King, Queen, Herald, Mason, Spinner and Knight. All of one suit. House Death. As Kalam notes, Hood's house, surrounding the one carrying the book. A portentous omen.
The next morning, an hour after Kalam leaves, the woman who we now see named as Lostara Yil also prepares to depart. We do not learn the name of her companion but it is clear they have killed everyone in the inn and are purposefully following Kalam, having tracked him here in the first place.
Mappo and Icarium are exploring Iskaral Pust's monastery and have discovered an old crypt with strange paintings and an unusual carving on the floor. One passageway is blocked by fallen stones and the pair move them, surprised at their weight. Beyond they find a hallway with solid wooden pillars and Icarium sniffs the centuries old residue of a warren which he likens to Kurald Galain. Mappo says that doesn't make sense as the Tiste Andii have never been present on Seven Cities. Icarium says he is uncertain, it feels like Kurald Galain only because it is elder but definitely not any of the other elder warrens which he reminds us are Omtose Phellack, Starvald Demelain and Tellann. Descending further they find a chamber where magic bleeds from the stones. Icarium says it smells like Kurald Galain but corrupted. They see signs of Soletaken and D'ivers here and realise that this is the gate. They wonder whether Pust and by extension, the shadow realm, is behind the convergence. So far, in the previous book, we may have seen Shadowthrone as a somewhat incompetent bungler. Was that true? Or is he simply up to something much bigger? We have a quote here from Mappo as he watches Icarium ascend that I'll use directly.
"My curse is to silence your every question, and the hand I offer as a brother will lead you only into deceit."
It's curious to see that Mappo knows he is misleading Icarium and yet shows genuine regret in doing so.
The pair confront Pust but he's having one of his insane moments and is obsessed with clearing out the spiders but has lost his broom and demands the pair look for it. Strangely, Icarium agrees and to Mappo's surprise, he goes off to look for the broom.
Ok, time for a weird scene. Duiker, Kulp, Bult and Sormo E'nath are heading to an old Wickan holy site where the warlock intends to... commune with the spirits? It's a little unclear what his intentions are but Kulp thinks it's a bad idea. Also, it seems the flies are increasing in number. We see numerous mentions of people swatting flies here and it's worth mentioning that though I'm summarizing, assume there is pretty much constant mention of flies through the book so far. Anyways, Sormo claims the spirits here are from Tellann. Duiker complains that Sormo will be dealing with T'lan Imass and that the undead warriors turned their back on the Empress after the Emperor's assassination. Sormo asks whether Duiker ever wondered why. Sormo begins his ritual and the shit immediately hits the fan. A D'ivers as a swarm of wasps attacks. More D'ivers attack, a swarm of rats, a colony of fire ants, a bundle of snakes. Kulp tries to defend Duiker with his magic.
And then a demon arrives and a huge white furred bear Soletaken. The shapeshifters fight the demon. Kulp punches Sormo to disrupt the ritual and the group make their escape.
Quick side note, Sormo E'nath supposedly has eleven souls which is what makes him so powerful. The aftermath of this event, by his own admission, cost him one of those souls.
The group speculate on what happened, with Sormo wondering if the shapeshifters are using Tellann to travel somewhere, assuming it unoccupied by the absent T'lan Imass. We, the reader, know that he essentially got a taste of the convergence which seems to be well underway.
Fiddler approaches G'danisban with Crokus and Apsalar in tow. He is disguised as a Gral once more. They hear news of a massacre at Ladro Keep. News spreads fast, huh. A whole bunch of shit happens here but it's not of particular import until they are almost free of G'danisban where it begins to come extremely clear that Apsalar has some very specific memories left over from The Rope's possession. This isn't necessarily news but.
This town is under rebel control and they've raped and slaughtered the townsfolk, butchered the children, it's grim work. When Crokus asks if this is payment, if the Malazans behaved like this during the initial conquest, Apsalar is quick to state that the Emperor fought armies not civilians. Fiddler voices the massacre at Aren as an exception, when the T'lan Imass ran rampant among the civilian population. Apsalar angrily states that this was not at Kellanved's command but at Surly's, the Claw commander who eventually became Empress Laseen. Fiddler isn't sure how Apsalar knows this and she mutters that she should have killed Surly when she had the chance. Apsalar knows she was but a baby when the events she describes took place, that they are not her memories but they seem so vivid. She remembers arguing with Surly about it. Crokus says the memories she holds should belong to The Rope but these memories are... Dancer's. Fiddler makes the connection. Dancer is The Rope. He realises that the Emperor's assassination may have been fabricated. Fiddler can't believe how stupid he is (and neither can we, didn't the Bridgeburners figure this out already?!). He realises the House of Shadow appeared in the Deck of Dragons shortly after the Emperor's disappearance, that the bodies were never found and that just maybe, Kellanved and Dancer didn't get assassinated but actually ascended to become Shadowthrone and Cotillion. What really stings for Fiddler is why Cotillion didn't tell the Bridgeburners. They were friends after all. Apsalar says Cotillion only trusted two people, Kellanved and Dassem Ultor. Dassem is dead and The Rope's trust in Kellanved is waning. The man, the Emperor, he trusted, but the god, Shadowthrone, he is more wary of.
Kalam is deep in the desert and it seems he finds it familiar. It seems likely he is from here originally as he knows about false trails, designed to lead people away from water and to their doom. He is stopped by a man and a giant, Leoman and Toblakai (whose real name is unknown). They are Sha'ik's bodyguard and check Kalam's possessions to confirm he is the genuine bookbearer. Satisfied he's legit, Sha'ik appears. Kalam hands over the book and Sha'ik speaks of something she has seen. She summons the aptorian demon. These things are hideous, have a google. She thinks Shadowthrone sent it into Raraku to spy. Sha'ik took control of it and has used to to kill D'ivers. She sends Kalam on his way with the demon.
Just before dawn, as she is supposed to do, Sha'ik opens the book. A crossbow bolt strikes her in the head, killing her instantly. Lostara Yil and her men, and her boss, Baralta, have ambushed them. Furious, Leoman and Toblakai fight back. Toblakai has a wooden sword and yet manages to kill a bunch of Lostara's men and almost her too. The group beat a hasty retreat, amazed at the Toblakai's prowess. Baralta tells Lostara to continue following Kalam.
Leoman and Toblakai decide to wait by Shai'k's corpse. Leoman is unsure what to do, but Sha'ik had opened the book and had previously told Leoman she would be renewed and so, he waits. Toblakai sniffs the air and claims a storm is brewing.
Deadhouse Gates
It is the 1163rd year of Burn's Sleep. 9th Year of the Reign of Empress Laseen.
We begin with a stark reminder that Malazan is a grimdark setting. We see Felisin, who you might remember is the younger sister of Ganoes Paran and she is in chains on a line of prisoners. It seems Empress Laseen has culled the nobles of Unta although it's not just the aristocracy on the chain. Next to Felisin is a large, bestial man named Baudin and a priest of Fener named Heboric, covered in tattoos resembling his god, the Boar of Summer. Heboric has no hands, his wrists ending in scarred, suppurating stumps.
At the same time, a priest of Hood is slowly approaching the chain of prisoners. He is covered in flies which have been drawn to the blood covering his body, a ritual in which Hood's priests smear themselves with the blood of executed murderers. This rite is part of the season of rot, performed by the priests when there is pestilence. The priest of Hood approaches the chain and exchanges words with Heboric. Then, suddenly, the cloud of flies bursts apart to reveal... no one. This unsettles Heboric and his fellow prisoners who wonder if this was a direct visitation by Hood himself.
A mob is forming and Felisin sees a familiar face on horseback behind them. Tavore... Adjunct Tavore. Her sister and the new embodiment of Empress Laseen's will. It seems Tavore was involved in orchestrating this cull.
As the guards try to move the prisoners, the mob attacks. Heboric protects Felisin as it gets gory. Eventually the mob are stopped when Baudin violently decapitates one of the female prisoners to appease their bloodlust.
This backdrop of plague, pestilence and violence in the Malazan Empire is gonna be a thing for a while. Our key takeaway from this prologue is that Tavore is the new Adjunct and her sister enslaved. Heboric seems highly respected and has been punished for challenging Empress Laseen's version of historic events.
We move forward, to year 1164 and find ourselves in the Pan'potsun Odhan, a desert. This book is gonna get very desert-y.
Here we meet Mappo Runt, a Trell, who is anything but a runt. He is in the company of a half-Jaghut with grey skin tanned olive green by the sun. His name, is Icarium. The two appear to be friends and it soon becomes apparent that Icarium has some degree of memory loss. They are wary that there is a demon somewhere nearby. They believe it to belong to Sha'ik who has an army nearby. Mappo goes to scout and Icarium sets about looking after his weapons, a longbow and sword.
As night falls they approach some ruins and we learn that the Holy Raraku desert flanks this one to the west. We get some subtle hints that Mappo knows things Icarium does not. They find the marks of many tiny claws near the ruins and realise they are the marks of rats, but not normal rats. These are the marks of a D'ivers, a shapeshifter who exists as multiple creatures. They believe this one to be Gryllen. Icarium laments that there will be others, following the Path to Ascendancy. It seems we have our first sense of convergence here. Icarium is following the Path in the hope of finding answers. Privately, Mappo laments that the answers will bring Icarium no peace. Icarium says he has lived for centuries, yet has no memories of his past. Mappo seems sad for Icarium but the moment is fleeting as they sense another D'ivers approaching. This one is in the form of six wolves, Mappo names him Ryllandaras. They opt to try conversing with him and the pack of wolves communicates telepathically. There's an exchange and when Ryllandaras realises this is Mappo and Icarium, he changes his tune swiftly, promising them no harm, that he was following the demon and came upon them by coincidence. During this exchange, privately Mappo hopes that Ryllandaras will leave before angering Icarium and "unleashing all I am sworn to prevent". They warn the D'ivers that the demon is with Sha'ik but he seems unconcerned, not knowing who that is. The pair think that he soon will.
We jump over to Seven Cities, the sub-continent north of Quon Tali that is under the control of the Malazan Empire. We're in a city called Hissar which isn't one of the Seven Cities from which this area draws its name. There we meet Duiker, an Imperial Historian and Mallick Rel, chief advisor to High Fist Pormqual (who is the commander of the Malazan armies on Seven Cities). Mallick is also a priest of Mael, the Elder god of the seas. Just for now, I want you to know, Mael is one of my favourite gods in this series. You won't find out why for a while. Anyways, they're here to welcome Coltaine as the new Fist of the Malazan 7th Army. This is a political move by the Empress. Coltaine was previously a rebel who fought against the Malazans and by putting him in a position of power, Laseen hopes to quell the potential uprising of rebels within the Empire. We also briefly meet Kulp, a white haired wizard who is a mage in the 7th Army.
We now jump to a boat where Fiddler, Kalam, Crokus and Apsalar are sailing to Ehrlitan, actually one the seven cities on Seven Cities. They have a run in with a giant sea serpent, a dhenrabi. They aren't usually found in waters this shallow but it soon becomes apparent that this dhenrabi is a Soletaken, another shapeshifter. The Soletaken warns the humans that it must kill them for having witnessed its passage. It attacks but Fiddler fires a munition from his crossbow and blows its head to smithereens. The Malazans are suspicious as to why the Soletaken was here. Spoilers, we know already. The shapeshifters are converging. But Kalam and Fiddler can't figure it out and so they continue heading to a small village outside Ehrlitan. Crokus demands some answers. He thinks Kalam and Fiddler only agreed to return Apsalar to Quon Tali in order to pursue their own agenda. The two admit it. Kalam is an assassin and this is a business trip. Kalam intends to assassinate...
Did you figure it out?
...Empress Laseen.
Dun dun DUN!!
Well damn. One chapter in and the stakes are enormous already.
Duiker has a walk around Hissar, giving us some local flavour before eventually arriving at a meeting with Coltaine. Also present is Coltaine's second in command, Bult, Mallick Rel and Kulp. We find a little of the history of Coltaine's fight with the Malazans. It seems Bult almost killed Duiker in that conflict before realising he was unarmed. Although he refrained, he was attacked by Dujek who scarred his face with his sword, but Bult's horse bit Dujek's arm, ultimately infecting it and causing its amputation later. Now we know how he became Dujek Onearm.
The meeting hasn't begun yet because Coltaine is waiting on his warlock. This surprises Duiker who thought all the Wickan warlocks were killed when the conflict was won by the Malazans. To summarize, Laseen ordered them all spiked up outside the walls. Coltaine is from the Crow Clan and they believe that the crows took the spirits of the dying warlocks and brought them back to his people to be reborn. When the warlock enters, a young teen boy, he claims to be Sormo E'nath. Kulp is outwardly dismissive but later, privately confesses to Duiker that the boy shows way more power than he has any right to and is probably the real Sormo E'nath reborn. Anyways, Mallick Rel says he has orders from Pormqual and Coltaine instantly dismisses them and Rel from the meeting. Duiker and Coltaine discuss some political issues. We learn that Crust was High Fist before Pormqual and that he drowned at night, despite being a strong swimmer and his body was never found. He was one of Kellanved's close friends and we learn that those are all dead with no bodies found either, including Toc the Elder and Ameron. They discuss whether it was Laseen cleaning house or whether someone else wished to deny Laseen the solid counsel Kellanved had access to. The meeting ends with Coltaine attaching Duiker to the 7th.
As I mentioned, Duiker and Kulp converse in private where Kulp claims the warlock is genuine and that he intends not to let on, in the hopes the warlock might consider him insignificant. They also express some surprise that both Coltaine and Bult seem loyal to the Empress.
Duiker isn't done. He has a personal favour to ask of Kulp. He wants help in freeing a prisoner from the Otataral Mines. Kulp is less than enthusiastic, Otataral kills sorcery, sends mages insane. Duiker promises they'll just be in a boat nearby, ready to collect the escapee and retreat. Kulp asks who they're freeing. Duiker names him Heboric Light Touch. Well, well, well. Kulp is still hesitant and when pressed by Duiker says he worries about releasing a second traitorous historian into the world.
Back to Ehrlitan to catch up with Fiddler. He witnesses some rebels killing people and in the confusion a pimp snatches two young girls whose mother is killed. One 9, the other smaller. Fiddler follows the pimp and manages to rescue the girls before they are violated. He returns them back to their people where they recognise him as a Gral, a tribe local to Ehrlitan. As a reward, Fiddler is invited inside to speak to a Spiritwalker. The two converse, the Spiritwalker has heard of the Bridgeburners. Fiddler confesses he is not a Gral but a Malazan in disguise though not to fool the locals but to hide from the Malazans and says he wishes to get passage to Quon Tali. The Spiritwalker tells Fiddler that he will not find a boat to Quon Tali and instead must cross the Pan'potsun Odhan. He also warns that the whirlwind of the Apocalypse will emerge from Raraku and that there will be a convergence. Fiddler makes the connection with the Soletaken dhenrabi he killed. The Spiritwalker says the Soletaken and D'ivers are being drawn to a gate by the Prophecy of the Path of Hands. Fiddler doesn't understand why the shapeshifters would be seeking a warren's gate. The Spiritwalker doesn't know either but suggests the shapeshifters might not know either, drawn by instinct more than knowledge. The worry is that the last one standing might Ascend, to become a god of shapeshifters. He gives Fiddler some sort of magical conch shell as a gift. Fiddler discovers the Spiritwalker is named Kimloc and understand this is a great honour. There are details about how Kimloc has history with the bridgeburners but it's not important right now.
Fiddler returns to Kalam and tells him about the convergence in the Pan'potsun Odhan but holds back information about Kimloc lest Kalam go kill him.
Kalam goes off and meets a shady guy who owes him a favour but is reluctant to deliver. Kalam roughs him up a bit. To cut a long story short, Kalam discovers that this man has stolen a book from Pormqual. The Holy Book of Dryjhna. If the book is taken into Raraku Desert and given to Sha'ik it will release the whirlwind of the apocalypse. Kalam agrees to take the book to Sha'ik and the spy gives him instructions of a ritual that must be performed each day he holds the book. When Kalam leaves, the spy converses with someone else. This unknown figure converses with the spy and we realise this was a setup. The book has been foisted off onto Kalam and the ritual will allow him to be followed in order to lead them directly to Sha'ik so they can kill her and stop the apocalypse. Getting complicated, isn't it? I found it all pretty difficult to follow first time round.
We go back to Mappo and Icarium. They were attacked by another D'ivers, this one twelve leopards. They killed it though Mappo worried as he saw Icarium's anger rising but thankfully it subsided again. They carry on but realise another Soletaken is following them. A bear arrives, sembling back into the form of a man, Messremb. They converse and as before, Messremb recognises Icarium and wishes them no harm, veering back into a bear and heading off on his way.
Next the pair come across a man on a mule. This is fan favourite character Iskaral Pust, a somewhat crazy priest of shadow. Some comical scenes occur in which Pust falls from the mule and berates it, calling it Servant and demanding it bring him wine. The mule wanders off into a cave. As the pair help Pust up, a man emerges from the cave and Pust continues to call him Servant. Pust offers the pair shelter for the night in his tower which is occupied by hordes of flying monkeys which Pust claims are a curse he has to deal with but that he has also made use of them as servants.
As they climb Pust's tower, Icarium and Mappo converse. They think Pust is touched by Ammanas (Shadowthrone, Kellanved, remember?) and might be slightly mad but extremely powerful. Mappo notes a warren opened in the cave when the mule entered. Icarium also expresses some confusion as to why Mappo is wounded and Icarium's sword has blood on it as he does not remember fighting. Mappo assures him it was nothing, he was beset by a leopard as Icarium slept and used Icarium's sword to defend himself, that is all. Icarium is worried that he seems to have lost memories again and Mappo assures him that if anything important had happened, he would have told him.
And so chapter two comes to a close, leaving us with many questions about the relationship between this pair. Mappo is clearly lying to Icarium, but is it for his own good? Are these lies an act of friendship as Mappo claims? Or is Icarium being misled? What is it Icarium is capable of, that Mappo seems to fear so much? Well, we have seen the power of a full blooded Jaghut. Is it simply his heritage that is to be feared? I guess we'll read on and find out.
Oh dear. Back to Felisin, who is now 15. She's mid-coitus with a man named Beneth and it seems she's doing so in order to gain favours for herself and Heboric. We get a quick run down of the situation so far. Felisin discovered her body was valuable currency on the ship over here, managing to get her, Heboric and Baudin out of the hold. A valuable manoeuvre as many left down there died on the trip. Now in the mines, Felisin has attached herself to Beneth, not the big man on campus but certainly second dog behind him. The problem is that although Beneth is content to make life better for Felisin, he seems reluctant to do any favours for Heboric, agreeing to take him off duty pulling the heavy minecarts but only to put him to work ploughing the fields. Felisin has her suspicions that Captain Sawark, the guy in charge, has orders to see to it that Heboric dies here and intends to give him the most punishing duties to ensure that it happens. Beneth gives Felisin food and she returns back to Heboric to give it to him. Heboric doesn't approve of her newfound promiscuity even though he's grateful for the benefits it brings. He has other concerns. Felisin has been drinking and smoking durhang. Felisin wants to say nice things to Heboric but finds herself being mean instead and the pair have a falling out.
Back in Hissar, the Red Blades arrive by boat. These are a Malazan unit of fanatics made up of Seven Cities natives and the ones who caused the ruckus back when Fiddler rescued the two girls in Ehrlitan. Observed by Duiker and Kulp, it seems the Red Blades are about to attack the citizenry when some of Coltaine's Wickans step up to face off against them. Kulp steps in and manages to defuse the situation before it gets ugly.
Crokus and Fiddler have a chat about Kalam leaving. Kalam has left to deliver the book, hoping to further undermine Laseen's hold on the Empire. Fiddler disagreed, focusing on the fact that the plan is to kill Laseen, not bring down the entire Empire. Crokus is worried that Apsalar's skills left over from The Rope's possession make her Fiddler's backup plan. Fiddler claims that's not true, but it no doubt occurred to Kalam and if not him, Quick Ben for sure.
Back with Iskaral Pust for some more comedy. Mappo asks how to get to the library and after Pust finishes giving him instructions containing a suspicious amount of right turns, the Trell replies "Or turn left, nineteen paces?".
He joins Icarium in the library. Icarium is surprised at the books he has found here. Well crafted, clearly expensive tomes, yet about trivial subjects such as seed dispersal patterns. What's more they seem to be thousands of years old.
Privately, Mappo is surprised Icarium is able to read the language. He tries to convince Icarium that the triviality of the knowledge was probably what led to the downfall of said civilization and even quotes Gothos' Folly to support his argument. He seems extremely keen to get Icarium off the subject of these older civilizations. He has a brief flashback to the time his tribe was approached by the Nameless Ones.
And back to the mines, where bodies are being removed from a collapse. Felisin realises that her actions have saved Heboric's life. Had she not had him removed to the fields, he would have been in that collapse. Indeed, the old priest has regained some of his vigour. Felisin laments that she and Heboric don't talk as much any more. He is upset at her durhang addiction but she can't think straight due to the substance, which I always presumed to be some kind of opiate given the dulling of mind and physical ravaging of body it causes, combined with its strong addictive quality. It has only been two weeks but already Felisin is in deep and many people here comment on her aged appearance. Sawark thinks she is nineteen and is surprised to learn she is actually fifteen. Anyways, Felisin has basically been offering herself around to fund this drug fuelled existence. Even Beneth is sick of her, describing her lovemaking as "torpid".
Beneth has a meeting with Captain Sawark, the man that runs the mines and takes Felisin with him. Beneth is seeking information about Baudin who has been arrested for violating curfew. There's some subtle hints that the two might have been friends in the past. Beneth is hoping to offer Felisin as a bribe but Sawark comments that nineteen is not young enough which is the aforementioned surprise. But there's something more here. Sawark pays her close attention and his face goes pale. The meeting ends swiftly.
Beneth takes Felisin outside and interrogates her, trying to figure out who she is that could cause Sawark such shock. Felisin pleads innocence, claiming to be a foundling who was at the temple of Fener when Heboric was arrested. Beneth thinks she's lying and might be a noble. He beats her severely but she sticks to her story, ultimately passing out beneath the blows.
Between the drugs and the battering Felisin struggles in and out of consciousness until eventually waking up back at the hovel she shares with Heboric, being attended to by the priest who is ministering to her wounds. She begs for durhang, for the pain and/or the addiction but is in no condition to smoke a pipe so Heboric reluctantly makes durhang tea for her.
Out in the desert, Kalam is on horseback when a sandstorm arises. He manages to make it to Ladro Landing before the worst of it and takes shelter in an inn. A Malaz sergeant tries to give him some grief but Kalam shows him a talisman that marks him as a Clawmaster and the sergeant drops his hostilities. A merchant's wife is also present with a deck of dragons, offering readings to the patrons. Another man and woman enter the inn, also seeking refuge from the storm. We'll cover them some more later. Right now we have no idea who they are or what they want. As the merchant's wife offers Kalam a reading and draws a card Kalam laughs. The card she drew is the Obelisk, a card that is inactive in Seven Cities and marks her as a fraud, with no skill in reading the deck. She tries to defend herself but Kalam rips her a new one, using his knowledge of the deck learned from being around it in the Bridgeburners. Angered, the woman chucks the deck at Kalam. Silence falls as the cards hit the floor... revealing a pattern. Kalam looks down to see a single card, The Rope, Assassin of Shadow, surrounded by six cards, King, Queen, Herald, Mason, Spinner and Knight. All of one suit. House Death. As Kalam notes, Hood's house, surrounding the one carrying the book. A portentous omen.
The next morning, an hour after Kalam leaves, the woman who we now see named as Lostara Yil also prepares to depart. We do not learn the name of her companion but it is clear they have killed everyone in the inn and are purposefully following Kalam, having tracked him here in the first place.
Mappo and Icarium are exploring Iskaral Pust's monastery and have discovered an old crypt with strange paintings and an unusual carving on the floor. One passageway is blocked by fallen stones and the pair move them, surprised at their weight. Beyond they find a hallway with solid wooden pillars and Icarium sniffs the centuries old residue of a warren which he likens to Kurald Galain. Mappo says that doesn't make sense as the Tiste Andii have never been present on Seven Cities. Icarium says he is uncertain, it feels like Kurald Galain only because it is elder but definitely not any of the other elder warrens which he reminds us are Omtose Phellack, Starvald Demelain and Tellann. Descending further they find a chamber where magic bleeds from the stones. Icarium says it smells like Kurald Galain but corrupted. They see signs of Soletaken and D'ivers here and realise that this is the gate. They wonder whether Pust and by extension, the shadow realm, is behind the convergence. So far, in the previous book, we may have seen Shadowthrone as a somewhat incompetent bungler. Was that true? Or is he simply up to something much bigger? We have a quote here from Mappo as he watches Icarium ascend that I'll use directly.
"My curse is to silence your every question, and the hand I offer as a brother will lead you only into deceit."
It's curious to see that Mappo knows he is misleading Icarium and yet shows genuine regret in doing so.
The pair confront Pust but he's having one of his insane moments and is obsessed with clearing out the spiders but has lost his broom and demands the pair look for it. Strangely, Icarium agrees and to Mappo's surprise, he goes off to look for the broom.
Ok, time for a weird scene. Duiker, Kulp, Bult and Sormo E'nath are heading to an old Wickan holy site where the warlock intends to... commune with the spirits? It's a little unclear what his intentions are but Kulp thinks it's a bad idea. Also, it seems the flies are increasing in number. We see numerous mentions of people swatting flies here and it's worth mentioning that though I'm summarizing, assume there is pretty much constant mention of flies through the book so far. Anyways, Sormo claims the spirits here are from Tellann. Duiker complains that Sormo will be dealing with T'lan Imass and that the undead warriors turned their back on the Empress after the Emperor's assassination. Sormo asks whether Duiker ever wondered why. Sormo begins his ritual and the shit immediately hits the fan. A D'ivers as a swarm of wasps attacks. More D'ivers attack, a swarm of rats, a colony of fire ants, a bundle of snakes. Kulp tries to defend Duiker with his magic.
And then a demon arrives and a huge white furred bear Soletaken. The shapeshifters fight the demon. Kulp punches Sormo to disrupt the ritual and the group make their escape.
Quick side note, Sormo E'nath supposedly has eleven souls which is what makes him so powerful. The aftermath of this event, by his own admission, cost him one of those souls.
The group speculate on what happened, with Sormo wondering if the shapeshifters are using Tellann to travel somewhere, assuming it unoccupied by the absent T'lan Imass. We, the reader, know that he essentially got a taste of the convergence which seems to be well underway.
Fiddler approaches G'danisban with Crokus and Apsalar in tow. He is disguised as a Gral once more. They hear news of a massacre at Ladro Keep. News spreads fast, huh. A whole bunch of shit happens here but it's not of particular import until they are almost free of G'danisban where it begins to come extremely clear that Apsalar has some very specific memories left over from The Rope's possession. This isn't necessarily news but.
This town is under rebel control and they've raped and slaughtered the townsfolk, butchered the children, it's grim work. When Crokus asks if this is payment, if the Malazans behaved like this during the initial conquest, Apsalar is quick to state that the Emperor fought armies not civilians. Fiddler voices the massacre at Aren as an exception, when the T'lan Imass ran rampant among the civilian population. Apsalar angrily states that this was not at Kellanved's command but at Surly's, the Claw commander who eventually became Empress Laseen. Fiddler isn't sure how Apsalar knows this and she mutters that she should have killed Surly when she had the chance. Apsalar knows she was but a baby when the events she describes took place, that they are not her memories but they seem so vivid. She remembers arguing with Surly about it. Crokus says the memories she holds should belong to The Rope but these memories are... Dancer's. Fiddler makes the connection. Dancer is The Rope. He realises that the Emperor's assassination may have been fabricated. Fiddler can't believe how stupid he is (and neither can we, didn't the Bridgeburners figure this out already?!). He realises the House of Shadow appeared in the Deck of Dragons shortly after the Emperor's disappearance, that the bodies were never found and that just maybe, Kellanved and Dancer didn't get assassinated but actually ascended to become Shadowthrone and Cotillion. What really stings for Fiddler is why Cotillion didn't tell the Bridgeburners. They were friends after all. Apsalar says Cotillion only trusted two people, Kellanved and Dassem Ultor. Dassem is dead and The Rope's trust in Kellanved is waning. The man, the Emperor, he trusted, but the god, Shadowthrone, he is more wary of.
Kalam is deep in the desert and it seems he finds it familiar. It seems likely he is from here originally as he knows about false trails, designed to lead people away from water and to their doom. He is stopped by a man and a giant, Leoman and Toblakai (whose real name is unknown). They are Sha'ik's bodyguard and check Kalam's possessions to confirm he is the genuine bookbearer. Satisfied he's legit, Sha'ik appears. Kalam hands over the book and Sha'ik speaks of something she has seen. She summons the aptorian demon. These things are hideous, have a google. She thinks Shadowthrone sent it into Raraku to spy. Sha'ik took control of it and has used to to kill D'ivers. She sends Kalam on his way with the demon.
Just before dawn, as she is supposed to do, Sha'ik opens the book. A crossbow bolt strikes her in the head, killing her instantly. Lostara Yil and her men, and her boss, Baralta, have ambushed them. Furious, Leoman and Toblakai fight back. Toblakai has a wooden sword and yet manages to kill a bunch of Lostara's men and almost her too. The group beat a hasty retreat, amazed at the Toblakai's prowess. Baralta tells Lostara to continue following Kalam.
Leoman and Toblakai decide to wait by Shai'k's corpse. Leoman is unsure what to do, but Sha'ik had opened the book and had previously told Leoman she would be renewed and so, he waits. Toblakai sniffs the air and claims a storm is brewing.