Page 1 of 1

Learn to DM: Tied Skill Checks

Posted: Sun Nov 02, 2025 12:00 am
by Charon
Skill checks. One of the most wrongly interpreted rules in DnD. The advent of DnD on Youtube and Twitch has led to an influx of people rolling natural 1s and 20s for skill checks and auto succeeding and failing.
Unlike combat and saving throws, that isn't how skill checks work and the main reason for this is that skill checks are not always against a fixed DC but opposed checks. In a stealth situation, what happens if the player and the NPC guard both roll a nat 20? You might be tempted to give it to the player and many people do, but then what happens if they both roll a 1? Do you give that to the player? Or do you now have to have separate rules depending on whether its a 1 tie vs a 20 tie? What if the difference is ridiculous? The guard rolls a 2 for his perception, he has a -3 so that's a -1 in total. I, a rogue, have a +30 to stealth and roll a 1 for 31. Technically, I should lose, right? Even thought it's -1 vs 31?

Or perhaps just scrap that stupid system and use the rules as they exist. They exist that way for a reason. To prevent this conflict. Rules as intended, my 31 beats the -1, because of course it does. Both roll a nat 20? The higher modifier wins.
Ok, ok, calm down, I can see you itching to say it and it's why this whole post exists. There can still be a tie even with this system, right. What if, regardless of rolls, both the player and the NPC roll a 15?
Ties are settled as appropriate to the situation. In an opposed roll, one player is setting a DC and there are rules about what happens when you meet a DC.
The guard is on duty guarding the castle when I try to sneak in. He is setting a perception DC. I am making an active stealth roll. My 15 meets his 15 and therefore beats it. I sneak in.
But this can work the other way too.
If my bard is in bed with the mayor's wife when he suddenly arrives home from work early and I dive into the wardrobe to hide, I am now setting the DC. The Mayor enters the bedroom and makes an active perception check to find me. His 15 now beats my 15. Same skills, same rolls, different results.
And finally, there is one situation where a tie is allowed. Consider a race or any race-like thing where two or more people are competing to do something that could potentially be tied. Whether it's first one to run to the end of the street, first one to find their target in a crowd, first one to shoe a horse, these are all activities that on a tie, can actually be a tie.

If you're still not convinced, consider one more reason why you should drop your auto-success system. The combat rules are designed so that regardless of how high someone's AC is, they can still be hit and even the best swordsman could miss a shot. Combat is dynamic and difficult. Same with saves. You can't just jack your save up and be functionally immune to poison.
However, this flat 5% chance to fail at anything and succeed at anything makes less sense when applied to skill rolls. You want to try and see bacteria. That's a DC 1000 spot check. Oh you rolled a nat 20? I guess you can see microscopic organisms. You want to disguise yourself as a dragon using only a sponge, three nails and a wooden mug? That's a DC 1000 disguise check, oh nat 20, yeah the other dragons are completely convinced.
Hopefully you're starting to see the point. Sure, just because a PC can attempt it, doesn't mean it has to have a DC. You can just declare it impossible. But what if it's possible for one character but should be impossible for another? A DC 45 Knowledge arcana check might just be possible for the party's high level wizard, but that doesn't mean the party's illiterate barbarian deserves a flat 5% chance to pass the same check with a nat 20.

The takeaway is to actually read the rulebook, once, and if you're going to change the rules, have an understanding of why they exist and what will happen if you change them. The internet streams change them to make things more exciting to watch and plenty of cool moments on Critical Role might have stemmed from this rule change, but even the pros make mistakes and Matt Mercer has been caught out a couple of times before, having to make a ruling on the fly about double nat 20s because he didn't account for this in advance and couldn't remember how he handled it the previous time. Plan in advance, after all, that is your job as the DM.