Monster Design Challenge #1
Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2025 1:02 pm
Welcome to the inaugural DnDGamer.net Monster Design Challenge!
So, as I've been working on the monster database, I've noticed there are plenty of gaps that could benefit from being filled. I thought what better way to do this than with a 'competition'. Ok, it's not really a competition. There are no prizes and the only winner is DnD.
The fun part is in coming up with something unique that fills a gap in the database and we end up with a cool collection of interesting monsters.
This first attempt is open until January 31st. You may enter as many entries as you wish. Guidelines for statting up a new monster are in the MM page 296. If you've never made a monster before, give it a try! Challenge yourself! :D
Each challenge will have a specific set of criteria in order to fill a gap.
The criteria for this challenge are as follows:
If you wish to see the only current monsters from the Positive Energy Plane to see what to avoid, you can check out the following:
So, as I've been working on the monster database, I've noticed there are plenty of gaps that could benefit from being filled. I thought what better way to do this than with a 'competition'. Ok, it's not really a competition. There are no prizes and the only winner is DnD.
The fun part is in coming up with something unique that fills a gap in the database and we end up with a cool collection of interesting monsters.
This first attempt is open until January 31st. You may enter as many entries as you wish. Guidelines for statting up a new monster are in the MM page 296. If you've never made a monster before, give it a try! Challenge yourself! :D
Each challenge will have a specific set of criteria in order to fill a gap.
The criteria for this challenge are as follows:
- Home Plane - Positive Energy. There are barely any monsters native to the Positive Energy Plane. Let's fix that. Natives only, no travellers.
- CR - 12 or higher! CR 2, 4, 5, 8 and 11 are covered. Lower is pointless as low level characters on that plane will probably just die, but if you really wanna throw something in at 6, 7, 9 or 10, I'll allow it.
- Type - All the monsters (5 or 7 depending how you count) are outsiders (with one elemental). Let's try get a different type in the mix, though I will still accept Outsiders because obviously they are still a good fit for the planes. At the very least let's get outsiders with something other than incorporeal as a subtype.
- Size - Not medium. All but one are currently medium.
- Alignment - Not True Neutral. They are currently all true neutral.
If you wish to see the only current monsters from the Positive Energy Plane to see what to avoid, you can check out the following:
- Ravid - MM Page 213
- Glimmerskin - MM2 Page 114
- Lumi (and Lumi Crusader) - MM3 Page 99
- Xag-Ya Energons - Deities and Demigods Page 210 and Manual of the Planes Page 169
- Vivacious Dire Tiger - Planar Handbook Page 131
