My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post Reply
User avatar
Magrus
Level 2
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun May 17, 2020 11:38 pm
Location: NY

My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post by Magrus »

This is the sprawling, not professionally formatted work in progress classless hack that I have been tuning and adjusting the past several years. I reserve the rights to this work, but leaving here for potential players to look over and soak in while I do my thing. It's a bear of a set of house rules which I laid out my goals in this thread: https://www.dndgamer.nl/viewtopic.php?p=37#p37 the other day. My goals to enable players to use the free to access Pathfinder ruleset without a monetary investment in a new way has grown over the years and I have step by step moved away into a more distant approach. I am in the process of a new revision and upgrade as of the time of posting this.

The basic gist of this, boiled down as best I can is as follows:

* This hack is an unzipping of PF in order to allow a classless character creation that is much like GURPS or Shadowrun while still using the PF Combat system, skills, feats.
*I unzipped Magic and turned it into a Spell Point, Components, Seed setup where you can take Close range + 20 ft burst + Fire seed and throw a fireball 50 feet away as a mid level mage with a variable damage, range, AOE target to adjust to your needs by manipulating a Seed (Fire) with variable components without the limitation of Spell Slots.
*I split AC into Dodge and Defense where Dodge=Touch AC and Defense=(Armor+Shield+Natural Armor+DR) treating the end result as DR.
*I edited the Equipment list to include Armor Piercing (ArP) and a passive sundering effect dubbed Armor Damage (ArD) with a Durability value instead of "Hardness and HP and rules for objects".
*I introduced a new Martial Training and Chakra system so martial characters can spend XP to gain buffs that operate on themselves without being a spellcaster.
*I reworked the Race Builder to allow folks to build a unique one off mutant that has unique and fun abilities.
*The "Class Abilities" that flesh out Fighter, Monk, Bard, Druid, Paladin, etc are listed on a tab of my spreadsheet with an XP cost and requisites for you to grab to fit your concept without massive multiclassing juggling.
*I am testing a Gun Rework in certain campaigns that fit the time frame of their illegal emergence on a black market. Basic races have been reworked to fit my game world.
*I have unbound Attacks per Round from BAB and hook the Iteratives gained to Dexterity. This allows high dex units to have multiple iterative attacks at level 1, albeit with the -5, -10, -15, -20, etc penalties associate with Iteratives. Dex to Damage has been removed outside of a singular magic weapon Enhancement due to this in this system.
*Introduced an Endurance system to keep the Pump Dex, Dump Con builds from going out of control. Performing combat or high activity actions (Run, Climb, Swim) will wear you down, making you go to Fatigued and then to Exhausted without taking breaks to catch your breath and regain Endurance. IE the Ogre who swings 1/round being attacked by the Elf with 22 Dex who is attacking 4/round will eventually reach a point he is fine, the elf is winded and slows down if the elf doesn't take a breather every few rounds. Leaving an opening for the Ogre to strike back while the elf has his hands on knees catching his breath.

With these changes, players have tools to build characters in different ways than before. I've expanded the XP granted at each level to allow folks to pull in new, fun combinations to play with, so these games seem higher powered than a number of other games. My world however, is built accordingly, so the challenge matches washing it out, allowing players more tools in their tool belt to be a hero or anti-hero. Some folks hate it, it seems overwhelming and unnecessary. Other folks have said "You've ruined DnD/Pathfinder for me, I can't go back." Explore at your own risk, and if you have questions, feel free to ask.

Note: You will need to scroll Down and Right on most of these tabs, and it is *not* mobile friendly. It's a sprawling beast and memory intensive as well as screen real estate intensive. It was built with a 4k monitor resolution.

I am currently crazy busy with life, but contemplating running using this hack here if there is interest.
Last edited by Magrus on Sun Jun 28, 2020 6:32 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Ricochet
Level 5
Posts: 116
Joined: Sat May 16, 2020 9:57 am

Re: My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post by Ricochet »

So, I've got a few questions, especially surrounding spellcasting in this system. No hurry for an answer, of course. Might be a bit of a slog to read through them.

First, as a bit of an introduction to give context to the questions; I'm a big fan of the spellbook play of the Wizard. The entire idea of digging through old dusty tomes to find or discover ancient or lost spells appeals to me. I also love what it does for scrolls, turning them from a consumable tool into shards of arcane knowledge worth poring over and analyzing. This only really comes up in a few places in 3.5e (Wizard, Archivist - the divine equivalent) and is only slightly more common in Pathfinder (Wizard, Magus, Arcanist, Living Grimoire [Inquisitor archetype]- probably others, as Pathfinder's gotten huge). This is technically a mechanical limitation on the character and probably considered by most as a disadvantage, but I really like the flavour behind it.

1. Is this sort of playstyle completely eliminated by this system? It appears to me, at first glance, there's no place for spellbooks in a system where there are no 'spells' - everyone has become a spellcrafter, and the only knowledge that is being chased is knowledge of the Seeds (or the other spellcrafting components), which can't be learned from texts or scrolls but only from spending XP. It doesn't seem like scrolls are necessarily eliminated - a mage probably can create a scroll just the same - but it doesn't seem like you can learn anything from scrolls, and there's no arcane texts to dig through or learn new things from, at least not mechanically. Don't get me wrong though - its not that I'm opposed to the system in any way as a result of this, and I would still be able to find things to enjoy from this spellcasting system - I'm just curious if the concept of a spellbook or learning from texts is still present in a way that I'm not seeing (I don't think it'd be as easy as "buying" the spellbook ability of the wizard, is it?)

2. The mechanics of learning a Seed seem to be that the player invests some XP up front, and then makes a spellcraft check. If this fails, the XP is lost. Is this the only aspect of character advancement where XP can be spent and (potentially) nothing is gained in return? Everything else seems to be a straight purchase.

3. Since spells are crafted from components, when does this 'spellcrafting' occur? Does a caster spend time in their workspace putting together effects in advance (maybe with Spellcraft checks), or do casters simply decide in the heat of battle that they want, for example, a fireball of such range and spend the spell points as applicable to the parameters?

4. The mentioned cap is "You may not spend more SP than your Caster Level." I'm assuming that is per spell/casting rather than per rest?

5. Is 'Arcane' and 'Divine' distinctions still present, and if so, how is a spell distinguished between them? I noticed a few requirements for abilities still mention 'divine or arcane' caster level.

Quite a bit here. Feel free to answer them in any order, one post at a time, or however else you want to handle them.
G1 - Gnutmyx
AC: 22 // Atk: +1 shld, +11, 1d4+1
41 / 45
D: MFang / EGift / Knck
0: DetM / CMiW / Mnd / Lght / PFD -- 1: CLW / Sign / DetG / CFear
2: CMW / InfWd / Sts / DPois -- 3: BestCur / Trmr / CSW
User avatar
Magrus
Level 2
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun May 17, 2020 11:38 pm
Location: NY

Re: My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post by Magrus »

Sure, top to bottom then.

1: You might find scrolls, or ancient tombs from a past age, but the need of a spellbook was removed in my game world and hence the mechanical need for it tossed as well in the transition from the last age to this age. So if you wanted to utilize a book, as a flavor thing I'm all for that. Magic is more of a "I know how to do this thing, I draw energy and do it" thing now with dragons in control of the world and reshaping it after ousting the old gods long ago. Driving them off, reworking the planet with a massive terraforming endeavor the activate the ambient energy that runs through the planet was one of their goals. Instead of the old way of the old gods taxing the beings in order to access magic and preventing free and easy use of it.

So if you want to play the book toting wizard you can frame it as you record what has worked and what hasn't, and out of character this is helpful in tracking the "spells" you come up with. It would make sense *in character* as well as a personal log of complicated arcane formula for spell formulation with the seed system in fact. It however isn't needed, if you lose your spellbook, you can still innately cast if you have SP and know Seeds and Components to blend together.

2: Correct, it is the only instance where you can fail in pursuit of gaining new knowledge (Spending XP). I let folks take 10 on their rolls here, so the DC isn't terrible to beat if you build for it. On the other hand, if you are a Charisma or Wisdom based character, it might behoove you to pick up Skill Focus: Spellcraft to meet your Spellcraft DC's to be on par with an Intelligence based caster. My reasoning for this is the increased power that casters have as they level up. They are weaker in the first few levels, but get near exponentially stronger both in possibilities of ways of affecting the world, and raw power. Mixing Seeds is basically a skill check to apply Quicken Spell, and the ability to pay XP to mitigate Still and Silent Spell and Eschew Materials all empower casters in the mid levels. Failure to keep up in Spellcraft and make it a focus of your character will lead to casters dumping XP into the trash can as a way to enforce people utilizing this skill as the basis for using magic.

I like to think of it like your wizard who might have written down his spell formulae wrong. Who upon trying to cast these spells fails, has a kickback, gets burned, has to take time to heal up and learn it again the right way kind of thing. Or how when you craft magic items, you lose part of your investment in the failed attempt. Manipulating reality and failing at it has a cost.

3: It's on the fly like a Sorcerer in terms of how to cast and manipulate Seeds and Components. So you as a Standard Action pull together the following:

Caster Level (Governs limits of the spell)
Spell Points (Powers the spell like Mana)
Range, Target, Duration (This is paid for via Spell Level increases and determines how many targets are effected, at what distance from you, and for how long the effect lasts if not instant like a fireball)
Seeds (The type of magical energy you are pulling together, like Fire Seed to pull fire into reality around you.)

You meld these together via force of will in an instant and cast.

4: Cap per spell yes. So at level 1, you can apply "Range: Close (25 ft) for 1 Spell Level" to Fire Seed 0 (Cantrip) and do a Ray for 1d4 Fire for 1 SP. Alternatively, you can walk up 30 ft and Touch someone using Fire Seed 1 for 1d6 fire damage for 1 SP. Once you are level 5, you can spend 5 SP and take Fire Seed 1 with Range (Close) and Target (15 ft line) to create a 3rd level spell that deals 5d6 fire in a line with a Reflex save. If you paid for Expert Range and Duration Spell casting Proficiency this spell costs you 1 SP instead of 5. You would be unable to cast this spell at level 1, because of the CL cap limit.

5: I need to clear those up, relics from an older version and on my to do list. Those will become "Arcane= Int only" or "Arcane= Int or Cha based" and "Divine= Wis only" or "Divine= Wis or Cha based" casting instead when I get around to that. There really is no difference now, and it's governed by whether you are Int, Wis or Cha based as a caster instead. Magic is just magic and how you channel it is what differs.

Hope that answers your questions and if not, let me know. If you have more, just let me know!
User avatar
Ricochet
Level 5
Posts: 116
Joined: Sat May 16, 2020 9:57 am

Re: My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post by Ricochet »

Thank you for the indepth answers - that covers everything for now, but if I have any more questions I'll be sure to post them here.
G1 - Gnutmyx
AC: 22 // Atk: +1 shld, +11, 1d4+1
41 / 45
D: MFang / EGift / Knck
0: DetM / CMiW / Mnd / Lght / PFD -- 1: CLW / Sign / DetG / CFear
2: CMW / InfWd / Sts / DPois -- 3: BestCur / Trmr / CSW
User avatar
Ricochet
Level 5
Posts: 116
Joined: Sat May 16, 2020 9:57 am

Re: My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post by Ricochet »

I gave the system some more thinking and I think I may have identified another way to reproduce the 'spellbook' experience of a Wizard, except without the spells, on a mechanical level. However, it depends heavily on how summoning works in your system. So, I've got a few questions relating to that to see if this character concept would be viable.

1. Most importantly; is summoning still a thing? The Summon seed has been blacked out, although there's a lot of special abilities that reference it as a prerequisite.

2. You've mentioned in some places that 'Good/Evil' outsiders don't fit the theme of the world (an aim to eliminate the stereotypical angels and demons etc?). Are Outsiders in general still a thing? They're also lingering in a lot of pages / prerequisites.

3. If Summoning is still a thing, or will be a thing, I'm imagining that it wouldn't be as simple as summoning from some kind of pre-determined list - especially since you prefer to handcraft each of the creatures and encounters in the world, resulting in no concept of a static, boring template creature. Is that a correct assumption? What would determine if a creature (type) is summonable - an encounter, studying the creature, appropriate checks, etc?

Depending on the answers to these questions, the following character concept might be / might not be viable. Of course, I'm not suggesting any changes to the system with the following; this is all assumed to be fitting within your current system and not require any changes, if I read everything correctly:

Assuming that a spellcaster with the Summon seed needs to have some kind of knowledge of a creature before they can summon it (study it, encounter it, obtain that information from texts, etc), this might result in a character having a sort of 'summonable creatures known' list that they need to keep track of. While there's no mechanical need for such a list of creatures to be tracked via some kind of book, it could be done that way for flavour purposes (which is something I'd be interested in doing for my own character).

For example, lets have a character that has invested into the Summon seed, maybe even planning on becoming a Devotee / Master of it later, and taking other abilities supporting it. They might also take some abilities from Ranger or Druid relating to creature knowledge - like Monster Lore from Inquisitor or Favored Enemy. The character's motivation, instead of digging through ancient tomes for arcane secrets, would be to learn about creatures and try to expand their list of creatures that they can summon. Of course, their motivations are multifaceted - another good way to learn about creatures is to encounter them, interact with them, fight with them. Their corpses might provide valuable insight, too. Maybe such a character would even have a little keyring with a few different materials like silver and cold iron, which - while mechanically wouldn't do anything - they'd use to test the weaknesses of creatures by seeing how the materials interact with their corpses. They'd record notes about creatures in a book, which would be their Bestiary, which might in time expand to multiple tomes and a collection of information on the world's creatures.

Would such a character fit into this system and the world as a whole?
G1 - Gnutmyx
AC: 22 // Atk: +1 shld, +11, 1d4+1
41 / 45
D: MFang / EGift / Knck
0: DetM / CMiW / Mnd / Lght / PFD -- 1: CLW / Sign / DetG / CFear
2: CMW / InfWd / Sts / DPois -- 3: BestCur / Trmr / CSW
User avatar
Magrus
Level 2
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun May 17, 2020 11:38 pm
Location: NY

Re: My Classless Hack of PF1e; v4.2

Post by Magrus »

Replied in PM on steam regarding an update of my hack on this subject. The "Summon" seed is now a "gives XP with a base to buy Type, ASMQ, and Core Page things" and mixing other seeds in grant the ability to pull SLA-like abilities which fit the spells the Seed level allows, or new RP options that open up based on the strengths of the seeds.
Post Reply