Goals
1: More organic character creation which allows for organic, less restrictive concepts to be used while playing.
2: Shaking up the d20 options that existed prior to my work, introducing new options while tossing old options that failed to work well for player fun.
3: Rid myself of Vanciaan Magic and the handcuffed feeling of casters. This is an ongoing WIP process which will take a long time and creativity.
4: Unbind character attacks per round from BAB and make it based on the characters agility (Dexterity). Reward hardy characters with high Con to be able to work harder, longer than the scrawny agile folks as a way to balance this by introducing Endurance. Combat is tiring and you can push yourself to exhaustion fighting for your life. This is now represented in my hack.
5: Rid ourselves of Armor Class with it's abstractness, which lead to Defense and Dodge separation. This needs work and testing, and forced Armor Piercing (ArP) and Armor Damage (ArD) into equipment.
6: Introduce new options for martial characters. This lead to a Chakra and Martial Training system test, cost reduction for martial things.
7: Rebalance the power curve for casters to allow Martials to truly shine in early levels with a "protect the apprentice mageling" feel that was in the original DnD.
8: Allow for a truly heroic, broad skilled playstyle option as well as a narrowly focused build option dual path in terms of how XP is spent. The jack of all trade skill monkey and the Master Earth Shaman divergent builds of wide or narrow focus are both legit with different playstyles.
9: Rebuild the races to fit *my* game world and ignore what is proper for others. This lead to a power balance using RP for the basics, then a redo of ability to survive in the harsh terrain of my game world I am building. Races that fit my world exist, those that do not are tossed as "FR or Golarion or Eberron Specific" races that do not exist in my world.
10: Open up and rejig the Race Builder to be something I can add options to and recost things as needed to fit for players and myself as DM to build custom "Mutant" PC's. This allows players to build dragons, giants, magic critters, tiny fey as playable one-off beings they use as PC's as well as for me to populate my world.
11: Rebuild Guns. Shame on Paizo tsk tsk.
12: Redo Animal Companions and Familiars with a NPC gold track, bonus feats, and better combat stats to survive in a higher XP level environment for characters which invest in them. Open up the ability to double the cost of an Animal Companion track to gain more than 1 for a "Beast Master" concept.
13: Rework the options inherent from basic PF1e into a "Cost based on Value" chart is my next goal for v5 of my hack. It is currently, largely costed out where level 1 abilities cost less than level 3 abilities, which cost less then 6th level, etc to just lift and allow players to rebuild classic archetypes like the Cleric and Monk and Rogue. However, this is not balanced in a classless environment and needs work. This is my next task. Divine Grace is a "Level 2" opener, but it's value is well above this and cost should represent it.
14: Introduce custom equipment for my world.
These are the goals of my system bound to my game world which I am working on the past several years. I currently run solely this system in order to focus what time I do have into it. I will use this thread in order to keep a seperate from the actual mechanics thread stuff here in case folks wish to discuss or ask questions.
Mag's Classless Project Info
Re: Mag's Classless Project Info
As I get food in me and have downtime with the little ones being peaceful playing in the backyard for once this month, go nature. I have time between bites to contemplate the direction of my hack from it's current v4 state which has many imbalances as we test things to a further state down the road. I need a "To Do List" so here we go.
3:Clear out Unviable Races, introduce ones fitting my world setting instead.
4: Roll call for existing games, consolidate the dead games that have just a few interested players into new games.
5: Evaluate options for Discord or new forum home options. Perhaps Discord+Multi-site if miracle happens.
6: Call for requests to add new content [Done]; Added: Investigator traits, Slayer trait, Dragon Shaman Auras, Technique Feats allowed with 2 nerfs due to system interaction tonight.
Edit: Revising as I clear [Done] and add new. Patchnotes of hack hold the changes.
3:Clear out Unviable Races, introduce ones fitting my world setting instead.
4: Roll call for existing games, consolidate the dead games that have just a few interested players into new games.
5: Evaluate options for Discord or new forum home options. Perhaps Discord+Multi-site if miracle happens.
6: Call for requests to add new content [Done]; Added: Investigator traits, Slayer trait, Dragon Shaman Auras, Technique Feats allowed with 2 nerfs due to system interaction tonight.
Edit: Revising as I clear [Done] and add new. Patchnotes of hack hold the changes.
XP Buy Examples
I did some test builds on my server to see if my adhoc XP changes might be viable for a 1st level party the other night, and figured it might be useful to dump here. These are just the XP spending, not the entire character with skills, feats, gear spent and chosen, nor the stat block generated based on the above. Just the "Spend 40 XP to complete a level 1 concept" skeletons that replace a "Level 1 Mage" or "Level 1 Fighter" that you would get from a 3.x basic system.
Concept 1: Tank KISS
LVL 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 3d20 (15 XP)
BAB: 1 (1 XP)
Saves: 3/3/3 (15 XP)
Proficiency: S/M, L, M, H (6 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 6 (1 XP)
Feats: 4 (Free)
Special: Armor Training 1
This is the most basic concept. Lots of HP, the ability to use all non-exotic weapons and armor, with 3 good saves. Choice of Feat Tax described on my Rules Changes Page which likely would be Power Attack and Furious Focus joined with Deadly Aim, Rapid Reload and Point Blank Shot in order to utilize a composite longbow at range if need be. 4 feats on top allow some customization, and Armor Training 1 is a step toward a career of hauling around a suit of plate on your back and either a 2 handed weapon for damage or a hefty shield to tank better. This skeleton XP buy gets you a tank you can spend feats and skills and customize. Tweaking the point buy lets you adjust and customize more.
Concept 2: Striker KISS
Level 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 1d12 (3 XP)
BAB: 3 (4 XP)
Saves: 2/2/0 (6 XP)
Proficiency: S, M, E; L+S, M (6 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 6 (1 XP)
Feats: 8 (4 XP) [23*]
Special:
Armor Training 1 (2 XP)
Weapon Training 1 (3 XP)
Duck (3 XP)
Bob and Weave 1 (3 XP)
Evasion (5 XP)
This is a basic "I hit things better than most to kill the fast" striker build. Lowering HD and Saves, dropping training in Heavy Armor and picking up a single Exotic Weapon Proficiency, double the feats for some ability to grab things like Spring Attack and Fleet with Light Armor to be highly mobile. Adding Weapon Training and Evasion if you stick to light armor, with two abilities that bump your Dodge rating gives you a lightly armored striker concept to build off of. Simple, and designed to cut through lightly armored grunts with ease, it would struggle against a full on tank who's job is to take punishment and hit back.
Concept 3: Unarmored Cleric KISS
LVL 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 1d10 (2 XP)
BAB: 1 (1 XP)
Saves: 2/0/2 (6 XP)
Proficiency: 0 (0 XP)
Traits: 2 (free)
Feats: 4 (3 XP)
Skills: 6 (1 XP)
Special:
Monk AC (10 XP)
CL: 1 (2 XP)
SP: 7 (2 XP)
Range:
Target: 5 ft Diameter or 15 ft line (1 XP)
Duration: 1 min/CL (1 XP)
Seeds: Heal 1 (4 XP), Armor 1 (3 XP), Bolster 1 (4 XP)
This concept sheds proficiency with weapons and armor, investing in the ability to protect itself by basic monk training on the defensive end. A buffer/healer concept that scorns weapons and armor but as of yet lacks unarmed monk training of the offensive nature. Great as a pacifist build as a support caster with the ability to grant magical armor and shield spells, grant a +4 Enhancement bonus to any attribute, Heal all by touch. This concept can advance into a full on monk/cleric hybrid capable of delivering powerful blows with his own body as a weapon, or be a dedicated caster who relies on someone else as a back line with no martial options. You'll note the 4 feats purchased cost 3 XP here as this is a caster build, lacking the "Spell-less" designation that precede it which grants 4 free instead of the 1 free this concept gets. The Target and Duration options are pre-emptive buys that really won't be used at levels 1 and 2, but with the ability to pay for them now without sacrificing anything it frees up points to spend when level 3 comes around.
Concept 4: Scout KISS
Level 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 1d8 (1 XP)
BAB: 3 (4 XP)
Saves: 2/2/0 (6 XP)
Proficiency: S, M; Light/S (3 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 12 (2 XP)
Feats: 6 (2 XP)
Special:
Track +1 (1 XP)
Sneak Attack 1d6: (5 XP)
Stick and Move (3 XP)
Trapfinding +1 (1 XP)
Uncanny Dodge (5 XP)
Evasion (5 XP)
This is a mobile scout concept. Able to track, trapfind and hit often this build can become a two weapon fighting melee concept or an archer specialist capable of being back line support when not running point to spot threats and deal with traps and tracking duties. As a skill monkey type concept, this guy can invest into 12 unique skills, plus 1 more for Human Skilled trait, and more if Int is higher than 11. With Feat Tax options, likely the Finesse Route here and 6 extra feats one could invest into low tier feat options most cannot afford in pathfinder like both "Skill Focus: Stealth" and "Stealthy" to bump the modifier you bring to the table at level 1 by 5, still have 5 free feats due to the Human bonus feat to play with. Perhaps "Alertness" and "Skill Focus: Perception" to do the same for your end as the point man in the scout role. This would leave you with 3 feats, 1 over a basic Human Rogue in PF1e core. Tools for the toolkit of the skill monkey, more options to play with.
Concept 5: Apprentice Mage
Level 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 3d6 (Free)
BAB: 1 (1 XP)
Saves: 2/2/2 (9 XP)
Proficiency: Simple (1 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 12 (2 XP)
Feats: 1 (0 XP)
CL: 1 (2 XP)
SP: 12 (4 XP)
Range: Close (1 XP)
Target: 5 ft diameter or 15 ft line (1 XP)
Duration: 1 Min/CL (1 XP)
Seeds: Armor 1 (3 XP), Cold 1 (4 XP), Fire 1 (4 XP), Flora 1 (3 XP), Ward 1 (4)
The level 1 Mage concept with a general assortment of seeds that give both Defensive, Offensive and Utility to a young mage. Handy with a dagger, staff and xbow, having not learned to wear or cast in armor this guy is a battery of spell power who can if needed generate a short term Mage Armor effect. Ability to control Cold and Fire in limited ways, throw out effects like Barkskin and Goodberry along with Entangle, his limit on their effects is just his level at the moment. Capable of granting a boost to Dodge, Saving throws and Resist Energy as well, he's a well rounded apprentice who just needs some experience to be able to affect the world at a distance with more impressive options. A few levels will let him send death at range or entangle the enemy in a wide radius with some XP investment to upgrade Range, Target and Duration and grab the Spellcasting Proficiency options of "Expert: Range, Target and Duration" at level 3 to negate the first tier of each's cost to Spell Level.
This is a 5 man party with my hack, XP buy setup as examples of what is possible in a very keep it simple stupid (KISS) model. More original, out of the box options are possible, but these are simple, core concepts folks can identify with that replicate the Fighter, Ranger, Rogue, Monk/Cleric, and Wizard of Pathfinder. Just a way to see where XP goes and how it is spent.
Concept 1: Tank KISS
LVL 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 3d20 (15 XP)
BAB: 1 (1 XP)
Saves: 3/3/3 (15 XP)
Proficiency: S/M, L, M, H (6 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 6 (1 XP)
Feats: 4 (Free)
Special: Armor Training 1
This is the most basic concept. Lots of HP, the ability to use all non-exotic weapons and armor, with 3 good saves. Choice of Feat Tax described on my Rules Changes Page which likely would be Power Attack and Furious Focus joined with Deadly Aim, Rapid Reload and Point Blank Shot in order to utilize a composite longbow at range if need be. 4 feats on top allow some customization, and Armor Training 1 is a step toward a career of hauling around a suit of plate on your back and either a 2 handed weapon for damage or a hefty shield to tank better. This skeleton XP buy gets you a tank you can spend feats and skills and customize. Tweaking the point buy lets you adjust and customize more.
Concept 2: Striker KISS
Level 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 1d12 (3 XP)
BAB: 3 (4 XP)
Saves: 2/2/0 (6 XP)
Proficiency: S, M, E; L+S, M (6 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 6 (1 XP)
Feats: 8 (4 XP) [23*]
Special:
Armor Training 1 (2 XP)
Weapon Training 1 (3 XP)
Duck (3 XP)
Bob and Weave 1 (3 XP)
Evasion (5 XP)
This is a basic "I hit things better than most to kill the fast" striker build. Lowering HD and Saves, dropping training in Heavy Armor and picking up a single Exotic Weapon Proficiency, double the feats for some ability to grab things like Spring Attack and Fleet with Light Armor to be highly mobile. Adding Weapon Training and Evasion if you stick to light armor, with two abilities that bump your Dodge rating gives you a lightly armored striker concept to build off of. Simple, and designed to cut through lightly armored grunts with ease, it would struggle against a full on tank who's job is to take punishment and hit back.
Concept 3: Unarmored Cleric KISS
LVL 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 1d10 (2 XP)
BAB: 1 (1 XP)
Saves: 2/0/2 (6 XP)
Proficiency: 0 (0 XP)
Traits: 2 (free)
Feats: 4 (3 XP)
Skills: 6 (1 XP)
Special:
Monk AC (10 XP)
CL: 1 (2 XP)
SP: 7 (2 XP)
Range:
Target: 5 ft Diameter or 15 ft line (1 XP)
Duration: 1 min/CL (1 XP)
Seeds: Heal 1 (4 XP), Armor 1 (3 XP), Bolster 1 (4 XP)
This concept sheds proficiency with weapons and armor, investing in the ability to protect itself by basic monk training on the defensive end. A buffer/healer concept that scorns weapons and armor but as of yet lacks unarmed monk training of the offensive nature. Great as a pacifist build as a support caster with the ability to grant magical armor and shield spells, grant a +4 Enhancement bonus to any attribute, Heal all by touch. This concept can advance into a full on monk/cleric hybrid capable of delivering powerful blows with his own body as a weapon, or be a dedicated caster who relies on someone else as a back line with no martial options. You'll note the 4 feats purchased cost 3 XP here as this is a caster build, lacking the "Spell-less" designation that precede it which grants 4 free instead of the 1 free this concept gets. The Target and Duration options are pre-emptive buys that really won't be used at levels 1 and 2, but with the ability to pay for them now without sacrificing anything it frees up points to spend when level 3 comes around.
Concept 4: Scout KISS
Level 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 1d8 (1 XP)
BAB: 3 (4 XP)
Saves: 2/2/0 (6 XP)
Proficiency: S, M; Light/S (3 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 12 (2 XP)
Feats: 6 (2 XP)
Special:
Track +1 (1 XP)
Sneak Attack 1d6: (5 XP)
Stick and Move (3 XP)
Trapfinding +1 (1 XP)
Uncanny Dodge (5 XP)
Evasion (5 XP)
This is a mobile scout concept. Able to track, trapfind and hit often this build can become a two weapon fighting melee concept or an archer specialist capable of being back line support when not running point to spot threats and deal with traps and tracking duties. As a skill monkey type concept, this guy can invest into 12 unique skills, plus 1 more for Human Skilled trait, and more if Int is higher than 11. With Feat Tax options, likely the Finesse Route here and 6 extra feats one could invest into low tier feat options most cannot afford in pathfinder like both "Skill Focus: Stealth" and "Stealthy" to bump the modifier you bring to the table at level 1 by 5, still have 5 free feats due to the Human bonus feat to play with. Perhaps "Alertness" and "Skill Focus: Perception" to do the same for your end as the point man in the scout role. This would leave you with 3 feats, 1 over a basic Human Rogue in PF1e core. Tools for the toolkit of the skill monkey, more options to play with.
Concept 5: Apprentice Mage
Level 1: 40 XP
Race: Human (KISS Free)
HD: 3d6 (Free)
BAB: 1 (1 XP)
Saves: 2/2/2 (9 XP)
Proficiency: Simple (1 XP)
Traits: 2 (Free)
Skills: 12 (2 XP)
Feats: 1 (0 XP)
CL: 1 (2 XP)
SP: 12 (4 XP)
Range: Close (1 XP)
Target: 5 ft diameter or 15 ft line (1 XP)
Duration: 1 Min/CL (1 XP)
Seeds: Armor 1 (3 XP), Cold 1 (4 XP), Fire 1 (4 XP), Flora 1 (3 XP), Ward 1 (4)
The level 1 Mage concept with a general assortment of seeds that give both Defensive, Offensive and Utility to a young mage. Handy with a dagger, staff and xbow, having not learned to wear or cast in armor this guy is a battery of spell power who can if needed generate a short term Mage Armor effect. Ability to control Cold and Fire in limited ways, throw out effects like Barkskin and Goodberry along with Entangle, his limit on their effects is just his level at the moment. Capable of granting a boost to Dodge, Saving throws and Resist Energy as well, he's a well rounded apprentice who just needs some experience to be able to affect the world at a distance with more impressive options. A few levels will let him send death at range or entangle the enemy in a wide radius with some XP investment to upgrade Range, Target and Duration and grab the Spellcasting Proficiency options of "Expert: Range, Target and Duration" at level 3 to negate the first tier of each's cost to Spell Level.
This is a 5 man party with my hack, XP buy setup as examples of what is possible in a very keep it simple stupid (KISS) model. More original, out of the box options are possible, but these are simple, core concepts folks can identify with that replicate the Fighter, Ranger, Rogue, Monk/Cleric, and Wizard of Pathfinder. Just a way to see where XP goes and how it is spent.

