The Problem with Slow

One rule: don't be an ass!
Post Reply
User avatar
Charon
Level 19
Posts: 1835
Joined: Sat May 16, 2020 1:40 pm
Location: Grimsby - UK
Contact:

The Problem with Slow

Post by Charon »

Have you ever looked at the spell, Slow? Like really looked at it, with the practiced eye of a DM? If not, take a look now. Anything seem strange?

It doesn't matter if you're coming at this from 3e or 5e, there's something odd about Slow.
My first inkling something was off when when I noticed it allowed a will save to negate while playing Baldur's Gate 3, a game based on the 5e ruleset.
Let's take a look at those 5e stats.
Slow
3rd level Transmutation
Casting Time: 1 action
Range: 120 feet
Target: Up to six creatures of your choice in a 40-foot cube within range
Components: V S M (A drop of molasses)
Duration: Concentration, Up to 1 minute
Classes: Bard, Sorcerer, Wizard, Occultist
You alter time around up to six creatures of your choice in a 40-foot cube within range. Each target must succeed on a Wisdom saving throw or be affected by this spell for the duration.
An affected target’s speed is halved, it takes a −2 penalty to AC and Dexterity saving throws, and it can’t use reactions. On its turn, it can use either an action or a bonus action, not both. Regardless of the creature’s abilities or magic items, it can’t make more than one melee or ranged attack during its turn.
If the creature attempts to cast a spell with a casting time of 1 action, roll a d20. On an 11 or higher, the spell doesn’t take effect until the creature’s next turn, and the creature must use its action on that turn to complete the spell. If it can’t, the spell is wasted.
A creature affected by this spell makes another Wisdom saving throw at the end of its turn. On a successful save, the effect ends for it.
A wisdom save, to resist being slowed. This immediately seemed off to me. I hadn't considered that Slow would affect the mind, causing you to move slow on purpose. I always thought of it as physically slowing you, the kind of thing that would be resisted with Fort or Con. For comparison, I checked to see how it worked in 3e.
Slow
Transmutation
Level: Brd 3, Sor/Wiz 3
Components: V, S, M
Casting Time: 1 standard action
Range: Close (25 ft. + 5 ft./2 levels)
Targets: One creature/level, no two of which can be more than 30 ft. apart
Duration: 1 round/level
Saving Throw: Will negates
Spell Resistance: Yes
Another Will save. So Slow affects the mind? But wait, why is this a Transmutation spell then and not a mind affecting Enchantment? We can see the 5e blurb above suggests that the caster is literally slowing down time, like this is a slow bubble around the target. That's kinda insane, but ok 5e, sure. That's certainly describing a Transmutation effect, but surely such an effect would be resisted with the body?

What about 3e?
The PHB isn't explicit about how the spell functions, only that:
An affected creature moves and attacks at a drastically slowed rate.
Which to me still implies this is a physical effect.
In 3e terms, Slow is a direct counterpart to Haste and the PHB has this to say about Haste.
Haste
Transmutation
Level: Brd 3, Sor/Wiz 3
Components: V, S, M
Casting Time: 1 standard action
Range: Close (25 ft. + 5 ft./2 levels)
Targets: One creature/level, no two of which can be more than 30 ft. apart
Duration: 1 round/level
Saving Throw: Fortitude negates (harmless)
Spell Resistance: Yes (harmless)
The transmuted creatures move and act more quickly than normal.
Yeah, you're seeing that right. Transmutation... Fort negates! The creatures are described as being transmuted. Exactly as we would expect with what we know about spells that physically change the body or its properties. 5e gives us no further insight here as the idea of harmless saving throws has been abandoned (so an enemy could force haste you if they want?).
Digging further, it seems Slow in its current form was introduced in 2e and in-universe was invented in Netheril as Quantoul's Slowmorph, still a transmutation spell.
Going back to 1e, Slow does not allow a saving throw (and is the Alteration school, so still very much physical).
Even 2e doesn't tell us a lot. The spell is Alteration and allows a save to negate, but saving by stat wasn't a thing yet. The only note in the PHB is that spells that exclusively target the mind (like Confusion) allow you to add your wisdom modifier, but Slow is not marked in any way that would imply it has this boon. Planescape Chronomancer, Arabian Adventures and Netheril: Empire of Magic mention Slow but add no further insight into it being a will based effect.
So it's not until 3rd edition proper and the introduction of the FRW save system that we see this division, with Haste becoming a Fort save as expected of a Transmutation spell, and Slow gaining a Will save for seemingly no reason, and yes, this is the case in the actual pre-revision handbook.

So what gives? What do you think?
Was this an oversight that somehow never got erratad and persisted through 4e to 5e? With so many people working on it, this feels unlikely. Surely someone else would have noted the dichotomy here? So was this intentional? And if so, why? What justification allows this to hold up through three editions, two revisions and bleed through into Pathfinder unaltered?!

It's a mystery and it annoys me.
Egwene shook off her shock. Verin? When had the woman returned to the White Tower? How long had it been since Egwene had seen her? “There isn’t time right now, Verin,” she said, quickly opening the small locker that contained her extra dress. “I have work to be about.”
“Hmm, yes,” Verin said, taking a calm sip of her tea. “I suspect that you do. By the way, that dress you are wearing is green.”
Egwene frowned at the nonsense sentence, glancing down at her dress. Of course it wasn’t green. What was Verin saying? Had the woman become—
She froze, glancing at Verin.
That had been a lie. Verin could speak lies.
“Yes, I thought that might get your attention,” Verin said, smiling. “You should sit down. We have much to discuss and little time in which to do it.”
Gimble
Level 5
Posts: 115
Joined: Sat May 16, 2020 10:56 am

Re: The Problem with Slow

Post by Gimble »

It's probably just an oversight. And I feel that if it was ever brought up to the 5e team they'd just hand-wave something like this anyway. DM's can fix everything, right?
5e gives us no further insight here as the idea of harmless saving throws has been abandoned (so an enemy could force haste you if they want?).
It does specify willing creatures, so I don't think it could be forced upon someone.
User avatar
Charon
Level 19
Posts: 1835
Joined: Sat May 16, 2020 1:40 pm
Location: Grimsby - UK
Contact:

Re: The Problem with Slow

Post by Charon »

Can you be willing if you're unconscious? ¬¬
I dunno, I feel like harmless saving throws are easier to work with than implied consent.

DMs can fix anything? I mean I'm tempted to run it as a fort save in my own games from now on.
Egwene shook off her shock. Verin? When had the woman returned to the White Tower? How long had it been since Egwene had seen her? “There isn’t time right now, Verin,” she said, quickly opening the small locker that contained her extra dress. “I have work to be about.”
“Hmm, yes,” Verin said, taking a calm sip of her tea. “I suspect that you do. By the way, that dress you are wearing is green.”
Egwene frowned at the nonsense sentence, glancing down at her dress. Of course it wasn’t green. What was Verin saying? Had the woman become—
She froze, glancing at Verin.
That had been a lie. Verin could speak lies.
“Yes, I thought that might get your attention,” Verin said, smiling. “You should sit down. We have much to discuss and little time in which to do it.”
Post Reply